Right then, let's see what there is to say.
Isa:
Personally I think it's a bit scummy of you to put him at L-1 this early.
How is it scummy to vote for someone you think is scum? While I can see that it is not neccessarily a good idea to put someone at L-1, it doesn't make it scummy. I think you might be misreading this. Also, trying to get others to put pressure on you so you would be involved in the game? I thought that Mafia was a game you were supposed to be involved in, not a game where you tried to make others get you involved. And no, I won't call you a hypocrite.
Illmatic:
Number of posts doesn't mean anything
Actually, in this case I think it does. Because you haven't been posting, you haven't been involved in the scumhunting, and so not helping the town. That comes across to me as if not scummy then certainly bad play. Furthermore, people who have posted many things have been scumhunting actively (case in point: Bulvious).
Dark_creed:
Not much to say here. Just a couple of posts, understandable as a recent replacement. And also some suspicions, although as I have stated I would have to disagree with the Otolia thing as that is pretty much how I'd react. Looking forwards to hearing more from you.
Bulvious:
I've had a dramatic reversal of heart (or should that be gut) in my feelings towards your alignment. I am seeing you as a voracious town player. I can see why you were pursuing Otolia, and to be honest I'm glad that it is finished (hopefully!), but I do think that he was trying to answer your question. Other than that not much to say, other than that I disagree with wishy-washy being a reliable scumtell, I am sure at some point I will show my indecisive side.
Otolia:
Despite the volume of posts I don't have much to say, as most of them are defending yourself (wrong words, but...) against Bulvious. As such, I don't really know what to make of you, apart from that it was either frustrated innocence or a good show of it.
}|{Opa:
Again, not really much to say. I haven't had much that I feel I can judge on from you.
However:
Sad Examples:
1) One stupid townie had created the thread in Mafia Discussion with some kind of question like this: "how do mafias speak in their quicktopic". Which resulted in a modkill. Town lost that game.
2) One stupid mafia had placed in his wiki-scummer-page something like this: "how dare *player name* hammered me", as a result townies used it for confirming innocence of *player name* and that game was broken.
That is actually hilarious.
verydark:
Again, not much to say. Your early confusion is quite understandable and as you understand it now there seems to be no harm done. Once again, not an awful lot of content, and I don't believe your taking Illmatic to L-1 was scummy, as it seems in the same vein as the cop confusion.
Maziek:
Just a question, why do you want to use colour all the time instead of just for special occasions. Not much of consequence, just wondered. You seem to have lapsed in your posting recently and it would be good to hear from you on recent developments.
So, I think that's everyone. To sum up my thoughts:
Town: Bulvious
Scum: Isa?
Neutral, but leaning towards town: verydark, Otolia, }|{Opa, Dark_Creed
Neutral, but leaning towards mafia: Illmatic
Completely neutral: Maziek
