Ok I promised I would put more effort into this game and I am making good as of right now.
ISOs on everyone, tl;dr at the bottom
:
Acosmist
- I have a hard time telling when this guy is scum. I've played several games with him on another site where he is treated like a Mafia Deity. If he's alive after two or three days we generally assume he's scum and lynch him <_<. That said, I've never played a game with him here, so it will be even more of a challenge to read him. Right now his ISO has tons of witty semi-troll/semi-protown remarks. I would have to say I agree with all of his shots, although I'm not sure if his Ellibereth case was serious. I like his latest post (#114), probably because something has been setting me off about Kwanton.
AlmasterGM
- first several posts concentrate on MPR. I'm a big fan of getting out of RVS asap, so I can appreciate his ratiocination behind his first vote. Everything I'm seeing in his ISO is protown. Obviously scum try to seem protown, but I don't notice anything suspicious in his posts. The only blip was what kiwieagle pointed out about the inconsistency of his argument against MPR, but I think AGM handled it in a protown manner--conceding the point and continuing the scumhunt.
I like his point against Sleepy. I'll be keeping it in mind when I get to his ISO.
DeathNote
- not good. 3 posts: one is RVS, one is "I'm confused," and one is "lol I'm not good town." I would say leaning scum but I need to see more from him before I upgrade or downgrade that status.
Ellibereth
- hard to read. First three posts were unjustified votes. I can live with one or two RVS votes, but three in a row with no justification? He later comments on his vollkan vote, but all he has is:
Ellibereth wrote:But seriously, volkan, first question post 39, something feels disingenuous and off mhmhm.
Scumvibes are sometimes the best factors for a scumlynch, but that case seems really weak PLUS there was an established case on vollkan already. One which Ellibereth ignored, apparently.
Response to Acosmist seems intentionally plain.
Scum avoiding spotlight.
Katsuki
- it's difficult to analyze what she's saying other than that she thinks vollkan is scum and that the vollkan wagon is full of town. I'm not sure how seriously to take her though. Her statements have that "you should just agree with what I'm saying" feel, but that's normally something I read from strong townies.
kiwieagle
- his analysis, particularly in his 2nd and 5th posts, have a solid town feel to them. Seems like genuine scumhunting.
LLD
- the only game I've played with her, she was scum and twisted my words to get me lynched. This doesn't look like that LLD. I like her questions to AGM regarding vollkan. Seems like critical thinking. I also like her kwanton vote.
Leiskyrie
- not enough to get a solid read on yet. Good question to me though in #82.
MPR
- I thought AGM's case against him was pretty good (and pretty cool), but having ISOed MPR, I don't find his posts scummy. His defense was not panicky or overly defensive. I like several parts of #69 in particular.
Sleepy
- do not like his 1st, 2nd, or 10th posts in particular. MPR's response to his 2nd post is good. His "I'm off to tunnel someone else" in 108 is just bad. And he picked me because I'm not taking this game seriously? That's not the case AND he knows I was heavily involved in another game recently. I spent several hours making a wall post in another game we're both in; it's not that I'm not taking this one seriously but that I just wasn't paying enough attention. Big difference.
vollkan
- I like his defense and he is right: no one really offered a good argument against his defense. I'm sorry I considered hammering without doing this. His ISO doesn't make him town but his reactions to all the pressure make him lean town for me. I like his points against Krew. If Krew flips scum, then I'd have to say vollkan is town at that point.
Summary of reads
:
Acosmist
- leaning town
AGM
- town
DeathNote
- leaning scum
Ellibereth
- scum
Katsuki
- town
kiwieagle
- town
LLD
- town
Leiskyrie
- leaning town
MPR
- town
Sleepy
- scum
vollkan
- leaning town
PEDIT: ok several people posted while I was working on this. I will update as needed.