@mod V/La until Monday, sorry exam coming up
I'll try and cover what's been asked>
Amrun wrote:See, what you're saying here is that the reason you find Hoppster scummy isn't a scumtell and that the ONLY REASON you find your top scumread scummy is that he is being so pro-town that it would be really bad for town if he was secretly scum.
Well it would, I don't like the way he took charge at the start, and also how he's sat back and watched as if we all think he must be town now.
It is far-fetched I realise that, just seems the way in which he started the game was almost to bold.
That being said I can see your point on him, I think I just wanted to make sure no one was ruling him out.
UNVOTE: Hoppster
You want reads on everyone from me ok>
Amrun> Very active and engaging, has clearly thought about the mechanics of this game and is trying to make sure everyone understands> Leaning town
DeityKabuto> Erratic and dangerous regardless of what side he is on, given no better alternative wouldn't say no to his lynch> Who knows?
helloonewman> Hasn't been active, not much to say other than "we should lynch DK"> leaning scum
Hoopster> If he is town, a bloody good one, if he's scum he's playing very bold, definetly worth keeping an eye on.>
Iceguy> not much of a read, seems keen to jump on my wagon though> null
Jillyne> Same as Iceguy, not much of a read> null
Moratorium> Active player with some good insight> leaning town
Quillford> no read> null
Amrun wrote:It does seem to be what you are suggesting for DK, though. Let me get this straight: we should lynch Hoppster because it would be really bad for town if he was scum because of his apparent pro-town behavior, but DK is unreadable so we should not lynch him?
Well not really, again wanting to draw attention to everyone not just one unreadable player who would be an easy mislynch if not cased out properly
Amrun wrote:
No. We would not be scumhunting or clearing people in this manner ever. Please endeavor to understand the subject at hand.
Right so we're narrowing our options, gotcha