130.Mirror Mafia - Game Over

[Tasky]

VOTECOUNT 5.3

Bub Bidderskins (LYNCH!): Pine, Nocmen, Twistedspoon, Ctorj49, hohum
hohum (3/5): Bunnylover, Magister Ludi, Bub Bidderskins

Not Voting (0): //

Bub Bidderskins, Vanilla Townie

,

lynched Day 5

Night 5 will end 10.06.2011 00:00 CET

[Tasky]

Okidoki, so another night has passed, and you expect to find some bodies.
Your expectations was correct:

Pine, Mafia Tracker

and

Bunnylover, Vanilla Townie

killed N5

With 5 players alive, Base Time is only 4 days, it will end June, 15th; 15:00 CET

[Twistedspoon]

yeah, pine looked mighty scummy after that bubflip. I guess redscum found it easy to identify him.
Mafia tracker too. should have expected it

good work hohum

anyways, this wagon is legit

VOTE: ctorj
just look at his entrance onto the bub wagon. Or his play in general and tell me he's not scum (not sure which colour yet)

If anyone does not have ctorj real high on their scumlist I'm interested in finding out why

[Twistedspoon]

eh

to make it official i might make a 'best of ctorj iISO 2011'

depends if I get the time

[Twistedspoon]

his iso has many votes but very few reasons

for example post 1306

vote: Magister Ludi

He is listed as not having voted yesterday. Seems like a good place to start as any.

considering we're

53 pages into the game at this point

reasons to vote really have to be better than someone not voting
if anything not voting is a weak towntell anyways

the ctorj iso is typical coasting scum and I'm surprised we let him live this long. It's mad.
My initial thought is that he's redscum but I might have to read again and other ISOs to come to a reasoned judgement

the final scum will be harder to find, but once we're all decided ctroj is today's lynch then we can crack on that afterwards

[Nocmen]

Hohum: has anything changef for you over night? Are you still given up on the game? Seriously, why the hammer so quickly?

[Twistedspoon]

I assume hohum will be in lighter spirits since he was right about pine. And if he's town we'll need him since our chances are slim right now

[Magister Ludi]

We are massclaiming now.

I would prefer this order,
Ctorj
Hohum
Twistedspoon
Nocmen
Ludi

[Twistedspoon]

why massclaim now?

ctorj should almost for sure be our lynch today since he's so scummy so why out A PR today for the remaining scum to kill after ctorj flips scum?

Lynch ctorj and massclaim tommorow. That is my preferred decision

[Nocmen]

I agree with the MC now.

And Ctorj first. Though I'd prefer Ludi before Twisted.

[Magister Ludi]

Twisted, you realize it's lylo today anyways, and will be tomorrow as well. What in gods name will waiting till tomorrow accomplish?

Actually, ctorj can go first and then do popcorn claiming.

[Twistedspoon]

massclaiming is all very well

but I don't see why we need to out a PR for scum to kill tonight when we're going to lynch ctorj today anyways

however if you guys Insist on doing so today rather than tommorow then I'll be cool with Ludi or Nocmen's claim orders

[Twistedspoon]

Twisted, you realize it's lylo today anyways, and will be tomorrow as well. What in gods name will waiting till tomorrow accomplish?

not neccesarily

both scum could shoot each other tonight if we lynch town

if we lynch scum (ctorj) then all is very well

[Magister Ludi]

The problem is no one is going to believe any sort of claim in 3 man lylo, and I'm not sure I even will believe one now. However, it must be done.

twisted, your thought on the other scum. Could be hohum?

[Magister Ludi]

Ctorj Is probably going to be the lynch today, regardless.

[Twistedspoon]

The problem is no one is going to believe any sort of claim in 3 man lylo, and I'm not sure I even will believe one now. However, it must be done.

okay you have a good point there

the sooner we do it the more believable it is

twisted, your thought on the other scum. Could be hohum?

it could be anyone

the thing is when yesterday ended I had strong town reads on hohum, nocmen and yourself. I was expecting the scum to be pine, bunny and ctroj

however the bunny flip has really confused me and it means I'm wrong about one of my town reads

I think the most logical thing to do is get the massclaim and ctorj lynch out of the way before we think about the last scum. After taht we should be able to get the last scum through PoE and ISo

The benefit of this would be that we know the colour of the last scum and therefore it should be easier to figure out who they are, no?

[Twistedspoon]

during the night phase I will say that I iso'd a few players and some of your actions, Ludi, led me to put you as a top town read. I can't see scum doing the fancy charts and analysis' that you did.

If ctroj flips scum then my first impressions will be that the final scum is probably hohum or nocmen but I'd have ISos and know what colour I'm looking out for to help me after the ctorj flip

[Magister Ludi]

Yeah, the color will be obvious. With three outstanding buddies (of each player) interactions should be easier to find than normal. It will definently help to reread again.

Just need perenial lurker ctorj in here.

[Twistedspoon]

actually...

If ctorj flips blackscum then I suppose hohum looks more likely scum

but if ctorj flips redscum then hohum is far less likely scum

I'm not buying that hohum and pine were on the same team. It didn't look like a bus at all, but I'll check again if ctorj flips redscum

waiting for ctorj then

Ninja'd: agreed

[Nocmen]

I think that the scum are 2 of Ctorj/Magister/Hohum. That's gut feeling going into today. Gonna get a thorough reread on everyone still alive though between tonight and Monday.

[Twistedspoon]

Im so happy my mini normal is finally in signups

just thought I'd mention it whilst waiting for ctorj to claim

if we're popcorning then I think I know who he'll pick

[Ctorj49]

Since some of you don't believe me that I am a townie, at least do this:

Have a plan in place for when I turn up townie.

That's all I ask. It's worth discussing. Anyone against that idea is scummy indeed.

[Twistedspoon]

okay, what's your plan?

who do you think are the scum?
also, Outline your reasons for voting bub yesterday

thirdly, you should claim now and tell us who you want to claim next

[hohum]

I'm all for a massclaim. I'm the town cop and I've gotten two guilty results so far. 1) Pine (IE me pushing so hard for his lynch) and 2) Twistedspoon.

Let's win this game guys.

Vote Twistedspoon

[Magister Ludi]

Sounds good. Can you list your investigations per night?

I claim Vanilla Town.