Surye wrote:Incorrect sir. I made an analysis based on the information I have that points to his claim being legit. He brought setup speculation into it.
That analysis is at least partly speculation about why the doctor wouldn't have any abilities though. Although I also am guilty of setup speculation.
Tahalindur wrote:Second part is very, very bad. Outguessing the Mod is a perfectly viable tactic - hell, it's one of the main points of asking for a claim in the first place. You just have to be good at it.
No, it is never good to try to outguess the mod even if you are good at it, it always boils down to a bunch of WIFOM.
Tahalindur wrote:Tell me, Zang: Where exactly did Snake say that the word "Allons-y" appeared in his role PM? I didn't see any claim to that effect.
He didn't but he also never said that it didn't. I also said IF it was in his role, I never said it was.
Tahalindur wrote:It is, but last I checked scum claiming vanilla outside of massclaim was pretty rare, and that name claim IS probably the best possible name claim this game (unless one low-probability scenario turns out to be true, in which case it is the worst possible case).
But what if he claimed the Doctor knowing that it would counter his vanilla claim.
Tahalindur wrote:Also, Zang: Thoughts on Nexus please.
My thoughts on Nexus have changed between a light town read to a light scum read throughout the game. Currently, It's pretty neutral. If you want, I'll evaluate more later when I have more time.
The Ruffig wrote:It's a pity you had to be scum, Zang. Oh, well.
So I'm scum because I don't trust the claim of one of the scummiest people in the game?
The Ruffig wrote:As far as outguessing the mod -- one doesn't have to look back very far to find a companion who would be well suited to a power role.
But look at The Doctor, there are several suitable roles for him but assuming the Snake's claim is true, he has none. That's why the mod shouldn't be outguessed. On the other hand, if snake is scum then none of this matters.