Bulvious wrote:I don't like the idea of confirming Maziek as town, personally. I consider myself to be an OK player, and I definitely didn't see Verydark's scumminess right off the bat. The fact that he recognized it so early is either just LUCK, or, as we've said, he bussed his noobscum partner for town points.
I'm just going to say that people caught what he was doing at first before I did. The only difference is that you all put it as newbie mistakes, while I called it scummy. That's why I don't put off newbie mistakes if they're scummy play.
For example:
}|{opa wrote:@ Isa, I'm sorry if my play caused the downfall of your great expectations. I'll try my best.
@ Verydark, voting No Lynch at the first day was proven to be genuinely bad idea (at least in all the newbie setups - it is for sure). Also, mentioning random.org is kind of not good. Yes, random vote stage is called random, but it better to choose by yourself. Some people on this site really hate random.org votes. It's better to provide some kind of explanation. Well, I did not, my bad. I voted Otolia for his serious looking mafiaso penguin avi. I know, it's a fat joke. Random vote stage often worries new players, just get used to it.
was before my:
Maziek wrote:Yay we started!
VOTE: Verydark
Depending on a cop for our scum is not a smart thing to do at all. Depending on night actions in general is something we don't want to do as a town. We have 7 people. We can put our brains together and find scum for sure.
No lynch is generally a bad idea in general. Especially really early during the day. We want to use our day to its fullest, which means getting as much information as possible, getting as many reads as possible, and doing our best to find 2-3 people that are scummy and we can lynch.
This is 100% what is on my mind right now.
Isa wrote:Vote: Maziek
Because the best Pokémon generation is Gen 1, not 3.
The thing currently on my mind is where the obligatory lengthy IC post went.
Gen 5 > 3 > 2 > 1 just saying :P
My next point was also brought up by Hopa:
}|{opa wrote:@ Bulvious,
1) Yes. It is my first time as IC.
2) Negative. I think Mod should force a replacement on those people who wants to be policy lynched.
3) Maybe some in June.
4) Don't know. I'd say south.
@ Maziek: Asking questions is good. Besides, Verydark had avoided question about his game expirience.
@ Verydark: Did you played forum based mafia elsewhere?
before my:
Maziek wrote:Keeping my vote on Verydark. Combined with the reasons in my first post, he has also been avoiding questions. For example, he responded to Jora's question, but he didn't respond to mine, which was said before Jora's.
At the beginning, I was not the only one to catch his mistakes. However, I was the only one to call him scummy for them. This led to me asking more questions about what he was doing, how he felt about me voting him, and things of that sort, and in the end his responses to me made me think scum, along with his L-1 vote (Which was pointed out by Isa before me). Saying that I was the first to catch on to his scum play is a mistake unless you mean I was the first person not to leave it at newbie mistakes. If that's the case, then whatever. Leaving stuff at newbie mistakes won't win town the game.
