Zodiark13, 242 wrote:xvart wrote:It is true. We are neighbors. I've been racking my brain for the life of me about our moderator and his opinions on neighbors since we were in a game together a while back and there were two town neighbors butHumble didn't say anything definitive about neighbors and alignments other than alignments are unknown. don did not talk in the neighbor QT at all pre game.
The bolded just makes dons claim worse. He conveniently forgot to mention that he doesn't know his neighbors alignment, which would be an important aspect of a claim, unless you are claiming solely for the sake of trying to make yourself obvtown.
While I agree that his claim was premature I don't necessarily see the reasoning for claiming as scum at that point since at best it sets up a 1v1 at a point where he really wasn't under any real pressure. A vote on don at this point is not the best play at this point because all the evidence is highly circumstantial. If he is scum he'll be caught eventually since we are both under a microscope. For the record, the game I referenced with Humble had three neighbors, all of which were town. The game is here so if anyone wants to look through it feel free.
don_johnson, 245 wrote:ok. recieved info back from mod. will explain in detail after xvart answers one question. mod said i could discuss the issue without quoting and that he would neither confirm nor deny anything. so depending on the answer, i should be able to confirm xvart as town or scum regardless of todays outcome.
xvart: please look at your role pm carefully and tell me if there is anything "wrong" with it?
Not that I can tell. Can you be more specific?
don_johnson, 246 wrote:xvart piles on a vote. no real reason other than "paramas reaction is town." that seems to be subsrcribing to fallacy "if parama is town, then beck is scum." its page 4
Not at all. My unvote justification was unrelated to my voting of Beck. I voted Beck because I always find it suspicious when people say "ooohh look at all the discussion I generated as a result of me being scummy."