@Ludi: Why would you prefer speculation over typical scumhunting?
WIFOM? I don't really know, but I'm going to trust scumhunting over setup speculation. And Cobbler has lied about his role, IMO.
P. Edit: I feel like spring was more likely as a vig kill. What do you think?
According to Albert, he recruited Katsuki because Kats saw his QT during Goofbash.
As far as I know, everyone started out with a town role PM except the two cult recruiters, so there's no need for any fakeclaim flavor. And I don't even see how having govern flavor out in the open helps scum fakeclaim anyway, since like you said, there wouldn't be two governors in the same game.
He goes from strongly against setup speculation, to doing some himself.
~~
But if he claims, it gives the cult more information about what they're up against, and about whether or not they'd want to recruit him.
Day Two: He implies he doesn't want town claiming, because it lets cult know 'what they are up against'. So then this clashes directly with day one, when he wants as much information as possible:
Also, what are you talking about when you mention "the fourth faction"?
Also, is there a special flavor name for your unrecruitableness?
it is important to me that you claim it.
@Battousai: I would also like to know flavor, please. Also, will the mod tell us that xvart is unable to be lynched?
I would be in favor of Battousai claiming where he was last night.
I think Darox should fullclaim.
~~~
VOTE: Darox, I suppose.
Crappy vote here, contrasting completely with his early persona of badgering people to help lynch Cobblerfone for a variety of different reasons. Also, where did the cobble suspicion disappear to? This is a vast difference in game play from early to late game. Its not like cobble is dead on confirmed town to you now, et your suspicion is gone, as is your lynch energy
~~~
Is this claiming a guilty?
A very tepid way to responding to something most of us assumed was a guilty. This reads like he is read to give up and self vote, I would expect town, upon seeing the same thing he did, to come straight out as very confrontational about a 'guilty' they knew would be false, or claim something that made it plausable. He knew he couldn't call Herod cult, though, so he didn't have many options, and the one he choose doesn't show town mindset
just ISO'ed Tanarin, and his play has been scummier than I expected
Blows off the 'guilty' immdeiatly as if it doesn't exist, for some WIFOM stew right here on another player, Tanarin.
Well, even if he did claim a guilty on me, I wouldn't be convinced he's scum.
However, when Herod does say it wasn't a guilty, he makes sure to say what he would or would not have done. Several posts later he gets around to it, with some other speculation.