Cobblerfone (3) - TheMask, Nocmen, Ironhead
Kcdaspot
Nocmen
TheMask (3) - Kcdaspot, Cobblerfone, vezokprika
Surye
vezokprika
Ironhead
sorasgoof
8 players alive, 5 to lynch.
Ironhead wrote:1. How do you know vezokpiraka is the bodyguard? Because of his unprovoked claim? Surely you don't instantly believe every claim you hear?
Cobblerfone wrote:The mod admitted to missing a night action. Both kills went through. You received a guilty on Amrun. Amrun couldn't have been the bodyguard. Peregrine's a cop. As far as I know the Hider went AWOL since before night started and probably didn't send in an action altogether. (Thus not missed.) That leaves bodyguard. And nobody has counterclaimed.
Cobblerfone wrote:And nobody has counterclaimed.
Cobblerfone wrote:The mod admitted to missing a night action.
Empking wrote:I admit to missing out one of my night action PMs
Cobblerfone wrote:BAs far as I know the Hider went AWOL since before night started and probably didn't send in an action altogether.
I can see you are quite passionate about this. Can you explain exactly why you think he is town? Bear in mind that we know of exactly three roles that would want scum to stay alive: the two scum, and the SK (because if the town lynches the two known scum the SK loses; SK wants town to keep mislynching while he NKs scum on the side). So Cobblerfone and vezopiraka's protestations of innocence make sense; but why would you be so adamant about Cobblerfone's innocence and Mask's guilt? Can you demonstrate to the rest of us in a way that doesn't make you appear to be the SK?Kcdaspot wrote:cobbler is town FOR FUCKS SAKE.
GET OFF HIM NOW.
Ironhead wrote:
I can see you are quite passionate about this. Can you explain exactly why you think he is town? Bear in mind that we know of exactly three roles that would want scum to stay alive: the two scum, and the SK (because if the town lynches the two known scum the SK loses;Kcdaspot wrote:cobbler is town FOR FUCKS SAKE.
GET OFF HIM NOW.SK wants town to keep mislynching while he NKs scum on the side). So Cobblerfone and vezopiraka's protestations of innocence make sense; but why would you be so adamant about Cobblerfone's innocence and Mask's guilt? Can you demonstrate to the rest of us in a way that doesn't make you appear to be the SK?
Ironhead wrote:You're right! Earworm probably didn't send in an action altogether, which would comport perfectly with what the GM said!
Cobblerfone wrote:Last night I realized Ironhead could theoretically still be scum. Depending on how the mod answers this next question:
@mod: Can the hider be roleblocked? Also, can you tell us what night the PM was missed?
Ironhead wrote:You're right! Earworm probably didn't send in an action altogether, which would comport perfectly with what the GM said!
If he didn't send in an action how was it missed? How is it a mistake he had to admit to?
Ironhead wrote:Cobblerfone, nothing of what you have said in your strenuous defense of vezokpiraka explains why he would claim bodyguard, or why he would protect Amrun instead of Peregrine/earworm/Ironhead, or how to explain his scum-slip in #919. If you had townie interests at heart, you would be duly suspicious of vezokpiraka and would be inclined to consider him a suspect. Your defense of him clearly marks you as his partner. That is why you will be lynched today.
Cobblerfone wrote:Last night I realized Ironhead could theoretically still be scum. Depending on how the mod answers this next question:
@mod: Can the hider be roleblocked? Also, can you tell us what night the PM was missed?
No. You think vezokpiraka is the serial killer. It is a credible conclusion to draw.Kcdaspot wrote:i don't think vezok is scum.
does that make me scum?
Ironhead wrote:No. You think vezokpiraka is the serial killer. It is a credible conclusion to draw.Kcdaspot wrote:i don't think vezok is scum.
does that make me scum?
However, I will note that you had the misfortune of replacing into Pine's slot and are carrying around the suspicions that he generated. I think that you are the most likely to be the real serial killer -- a conclusion supported by Pine's words and actions (such as yesterday's quickhammer), as well as your own intransigence regarding lynching Cobblerfone. I don't think you have anything to fear for at least another day, as the town desperately needs to kill scum before worrying about the SK -- which means the town path to victory lies in lynching Cobblerfone and vezokpiraka over the next two days, and then lynching the SK. Over these next two days, if you can convince enough people that you aren't the SK, you may yet win -- but remember, you are defending Pine's words and actions as well as your own.
vezokpiraka wrote:Oh crap I just found out something.
I'm going to die tomorrow to save ironhead if the scum kill him which I see no reason not to.