Honest Abel wrote:I see no conclusive evidence that whilst is scum, and you flipping town won't change that.
Good luck finding a conclusive evidence for someone being scum. I'd really like to see you doing it. Maybe it'll change my way of thinking.
Honest Abel wrote:Maybe "conclusive" and "evidence" are strong words, but any information we can glean from your lynchbait tactic will be useless. It will not be as good as the information that good ol' scumhunting reveals.
dicknose wrote:Honest Abel wrote:
DarkClaymore wrote:
DarkClaymore wrote:dicknose wrote:why is whilst more scummy than me?
He did something that appeared like indirectly defending me while arguing with Abel.
DarkClaymore wrote:Appearing scummy will most likely not make me a night kill target, thus keeping me alive longer in case I manage to avoid lynch. Of course, you can claim that in a way it harms the town as I become a suspect and possibly draw attention away from the real scum, but I find it very interesting to see the reactions of people when it comes to lynching a player who plays like this. Scum tend to slip in such situations.
DarkClaymore wrote:Scum tend to slip away like this a lot. Playing the "somewhat suspected" role which can be used as a reason to explain why the player wasn't night killed, while in the same time not being suspected enough to get lynched. A very simple and efficient scum strategy.
DarkClaymore wrote:I don't feel too confident as town or even I would have been mafia.
DarkClaymore wrote:Well, obviously I'd say that Abel working so hard to make me look like scum is heading in the wrong direction since I'm town.
DarkClaymore wrote:Of course, you can claim that in a way it harms the town as I become a suspect and possibly draw attention away from the real scum
DarkClaymore wrote:You can lynch me if you want. ... it'll still be a townie lynch
DarkClaymore wrote:How I hate when people say this... Well YEAH? I'm also town. What do you have to say about this? Huh? HUH?
DarkClaymore wrote:So you say it was all to please both you and me?
That's just going too far.
He can't just come and say he really suspects me and then, when I really become suspicious to ALL of you, he suddenly says "nah, I have nothing on you". Where did the previous reasons go to? What about the fact I created many new ones?
You just call that pleasing? I think that's going beyond it. Far beyond.
whilst wrote:
Honest Abel wrote:I completely disagree that NS is being overly protown. He's hardly done anything yet. Still chilling in my null box.
The thing that struck me over and over again about D2 DC is that he admitted he was being lynchbait early on and then just kept being scummy. He didn't do anything active until #380 that I remember. He's just been sitting back and defending himself for being purposely scummy.I still have to think about it, but maybe I can't picture town doing that at all.
I Am Innocent wrote:dicknose wrote:i have a couple questions. townies, what's your strategy? mafiosos, what is yours?
My strategy is to make people take stances. I'll be pushing people to identify who they suspect and what not. That and analyzing vote histories are two of the bigger parts of my scumhunting game.
Too bad surviving nightkills isn't the point of the game. Nightkills is gonna happen no matter what. That is a terrible excuse to use in this game unless he's a Fool or some kind of role that just needs to stay alive (e.g., Mafia). There are no Fools in newbie games.cavjj wrote:Abel the only reason why I asked that, is that in a strange sort of way I'm starting to see where he's coming from. I think he's gone about it totally the wrong way and I personally wouldn't play that way, but I think he has pretty much survived a night kill with his D2 play if he survives the lynch.
Honest Abel wrote:If we end up lynching someone other than DarkClaymore, I need to know that he's not going to pull the same hijinks on D3. DC, please do not keep doing the same thing the whole game. We've provided a ton of reasons why it's not a good strategy. It's just not. Move on.