All right, I am in no mood to waste a lot of time to wrapping quote tags arount the things Johhog said, so i will do it per point.
1. Yeah you can. At least more than leaving them alone (or agreeing with them) like you nearly did. But for scum it's better to follow the biggest wagons, as that would more likely result in a town lynch. (of course, if they are town)
2. I gave up on NK-analysis in newbie games. I only use it when there is such an obvious reason for it. Anyways, the point I made didn't reach you. You thought about the reason for the night kill (as is shown in your post), but still told us the idea. Later on you vanish your idea with a reason that is easy enough to think about yourself. How convenient to do that after being called out for it.
3. No need for ad hom. Off course thinking is needed when rereading, but going for an obv-scumteam read is bad if that wasn't even noticed before.
4. It's not nitpicking, it is showing why you adjusted your opinion to an positive effect.
5. Ooh, self-meta. No other defense any more? Scum like to self-meta.
6. No you shouldn't when they were already confirmed scum to you. Especially if you tried to link him in a scumteam, something that means that he is already conf. scum to you. Also, this answer has no relation as the question wasn't about that.
7. That's all? I'm not lying. I called theamatuer theam all the time, and we aren't a scumteam.
8. Why? I told in every point seperately why it you were wrong. There is no need to say every thing again.
I have thought about the 4nx-Aeryung scum-team. It would make sense (4nx voting Johhog, waiting for me to vote so AeR could quickhammer), but AeR is too much of a town read to me.
Let's end this.
Vote: Johhog
This way, if Stels/AeR post without voting Johhog, these are the only teams left:
Every one with Johhog
4nx-CS.