Okay.
For the sake of brevity, I won't give in-depth post summaries, because VM did that and to be honest it annoyed the hell out of me. If anyone wants reasoning on a specific point, just let me know. Also, please be aware that I am not a very good reader, although English IS my native language, hence the time it's taken to read the thread. If I misquote or misunderstand you,
please do not take it out of context.
So.
I find AurorusVox an overall slightly leaning town read. You'res scummy due to your constant vote-switching with somewhat... interesting reasoning (see
here, then
here, here with added weird logic) however your logic with NS follows, and the fact that you're offering a 1for1 is a towntell in my book, enough to override your odd voting FOR NOW, but which I see from your meta isn't your usual play. Interesting.
I find Nobody Special actually a scum read. The excessive tunnelling of Whiskers at the beginning was... excessive. So, to prove a point, here's a question for you.
What stopped you from actually playing the game WHILST you were aggressively pursuing Whiskers?
Failing an answer to this, I will repeat it in larger and larger letters whilst actively seeking to not play the game. Cause that is so totally pro-town.
Also, you
did not unvote Rainbowdash
after she explained her gambit. It was a failed gambit, and probably wasn't such a great idea from the start, but your vote was based on the fact that...
A) she was an idiot, or B)...?
(That was a second question, for the record.)
I read Rainbowdash as town, simply put. No REAL scumtells, a few towntells, and seems to be actively hunting scum.
I read Christine as leaning town. No real scumtells, but no real towntells either, other than a general sense of mild townieness. Not really sure what else to say.
I read Friend as leaning scum. Slight anti-town style, and s/he hasn't read the setup, and yet ignores Rainbow's question on whether s/he's trolling or not.
I read Alnara as... active lurking scum. Has anyone actually read their ISO? They have 11 posts,
6
of which are non-game related, and of the other 5, one is a seemingly random vote, one almost looks like RVS... 100 posts and 2 MW days into the game, one is the Hiraki defence, one is some strangely logical KJvsHH debate, and one is a list of all the people they find "scummy", but with the reasoning taken SO FAR out of context.
I read Whiskers as null. Completely null, I can't see any town or scumtells in what he's saying. I do find his avoidance of NS's incessant questioning a little off, but that's not screaming town/scumtell to me.
Hiraki, I really really really hate lurkers. REALLY hate them. And you are one. I can't get a read on you because most everything you've said is worthless. Start playing, or request replacement please, just stop screwing the game up.
I read killerjester as null with a tad of town. Seems to be trying to scumhunt. Be careful hoever that you don't try too hard, lest you appear scummy.
I read Nintendo as town, his logic makes sense and he is also actively scumhunting, pushing the game forward. I do agree however that the logic surrounding the whole "ad hom" controversy was a little shady.
Now. The big question.
I read Voidedmafia as leaning town. A bit of content, and some good scumhunting. Not much, but it's there.
I believe that's everyone. With regards to the above, I feel my votes would be best placed here:
VOTE: Nobody Special
VOTE: Alnara
Any questions/response to my questions *ahem*
*ahem*
