NY 142: Rolling in the Deep, WAIT WAT? PARTY OVER?!

[Sky]

What's the case for funk as obvtown? Not being the lynch is understandable I suppose, he could be a newb and all. But obvtown? I don't see it.

Also, Rev, can you give me a clear answer: are you the vig or not?

Unvote:funkybike

Imma iso SV

[DarthYoshi]

Day One, Vote Count the Baker's Dozen:

Shattered Viewpoint (4): sorgster, vijay2vasandani, Pine, Beck
Revenus (3): DavidParker, Shattered Viewpoint, funkybike1
Popsofctown (3): ZeL1Nk, bvoigt, Zdenek
vijay2vasandani (2): IAAUN/Faraday, popsofctown
funkybike1 (2): theamatuer, SodaSpirit17
Slandaar (1): ThAdmiral
Zdenek (1): Hiraki
Beck (1): Revenus
ThAdmiral (1): Slandaar
Not Voting (3): Primate, sword_of_omens, ScreamingHawk

WITH TWENTY-TWO ALIVE, IT'S TWELVE TO LYNCH.
DEADLINE: NOVEMBER 2ND @ 10PM PACIFIC STANDARD TIME.

[/quote]

[theamatuer]

Day One, Vote Count the Baker's Dozen:

Shattered Viewpoint (4): sorgster, vijay2vasandani, Pine, Beck
Revenus (3): DavidParker, Shattered Viewpoint, funkybike1
Popsofctown (3): ZeL1Nk, bvoigt, Zdenek
vijay2vasandani (2): IAAUN/Faraday, popsofctown
funkybike1 (2): theamatuer, SodaSpirit17
Slandaar (1): ThAdmiral
Zdenek (1): Hiraki
Beck (1): Revenus
ThAdmiral (1): Slandaar
Not Voting (3): Primate, sword_of_omens, ScreamingHawk

WITH TWENTY-TWO ALIVE, IT'S TWELVE TO LYNCH.
DEADLINE: NOVEMBER 2ND @ 10PM PACIFIC STANDARD TIME.

[|quote]

that fail copypaste.
alsoUNVOTE: funky
VOTE: Shattered Viewpoint

[Revenus]

What's the case for funk as obvtown? Not being the lynch is understandable I suppose, he could be a newb and all. But obvtown? I don't see it.

Also, Rev, can you give me a clear answer: are you the vig or not?

Unvote:funkybike

Imma iso SV

of course i'm not, that would be silly.

[Slandaar]

@theama: why are you voting SV? reasons for his scummyness please

[Slandaar]

@Sky: what is your opinion of SV then now?

[Beck]

@theama: why are you voting SV? reasons for his scummyness please

why are you not voting for SV? reason for his townyness please

[Slandaar]

delusions of grandeur != scum

I dont mind the lynch as I have said, but its not really a lynch based on scummyness from what I have seen.

[theamatuer]

well I feel that he's about equal scumminess with pops, so I just chose the wagon with the most support.
Plus Beck was on the wagon.

[popsofctown]

The issue isn't wagon hopping. The issue is lack of original thought.

[Beck]

well I feel that he's about equal scumminess with pops, so I just chose the wagon with the most support.
Plus Beck was on the wagon.

what does my being on the wagon have to do with the price of rice in china?

[Beck]

The issue isn't wagon hopping. The issue is lack of original thought.

Until I realize someone scummier, vote: thamatuer

No initial reads off the new material is very bad, adding to my other concerns.

vote Shattered

oh yeah lack of original thoughts, because these are really good examples of original thought from you (sarcasm)

[ThAdmiral]

Oh great. Just 13 pages to read. I'm not going to be done this evening but I'll chip away at it. There'll probably be 10 more of the bastards tomorrow. Thanks in advance for that.

- Page 30 -

Both of you, can you give me your top 2 scum and town reads, and if you can a brief explanation of why.

I also would like both to comment on the back and forth between rev and myself, and the points we both have brought up on each other.

top 2 scum: sky and slandaar. I've mentioned why a bunch of times.
I've got a bunch of town reads. Pretty strong one's in there as well. I've named some names already but I don't want to put out an easy list for the mafia to use.

rev and you: as I said before I honestly think it's town v town and the only thing it's achieving is bogging down the thread.

I will respond later tonight, but I will quickly point out this;

I feel like the scum is sitting back and sniping. In any case it's what I'd do as scum.

What has funky been doing exactly? yeah sitting back and sniping (bussing) so, how did you get this magical funky is town read? because his wagon was going too well? but wait a second, wasnt funky doing exactly what you think the scum are? so the votes should be vindicated from your standpoint surely?

No, basically. Who's he bussing btw? I thought you said I knew funky was town?

he says funky has been doing exactly what he expects scum to have been doing as shown in my #739

No again. He's not been sniping he's been trolling.

OK, nitpicking a bit but the wording here is pretty bad 'I will say' townies would just start with I think... its like he was thinking of NOT saying this which again backs the theory funkys town and ThAd knows it, hes saying 'i will say this' in defence of funky which means he didn't really want to defend him. AND of course, for a town read he really didnt do much to stop the wagon this is all he said about it and for such a strong town read too... that is very scummy especially the fact he wasnt going to say it in the first place.

Ok I'm done with this. If you're going to try to bring syntax up as an actual point you've more or less conceded the argument anyway.

@ everyone else: does anyone else see how slandaars case on me has changed from "he knows funky is town", to "not using same logic for beck's wagon", to "there's no way he could assume funky is town", to "he's justifying his sky read". Plus he is saying that I "know that funky is town" while at the same time is claiming funky is actually scum...
Guy's scum. Vote him.

[ThAdmiral]

- page 31 -

In this case, I think I'll be able to get reads on ThAd and Slandaar because of the wagon, when I get a chance to analyze their posts thoroughly.

No time like the present bro.

reads more of page

yayyy! more beck and revenus.

- page 32 -

Statements like "youre both town" scream: "I know you're both town because I know who everone in town is and it suits my purpose to tell you who is town because guess what? I'm scum"

How would this actually suit the scum though? If he died you guys would be more or less confirmed.

also... yayyy! more beck and revenus.

- page 33 -

@ Beck: Honestly the effort you are putting in to this, especially with posts like 806, is amazing. But please stop.

Slandaar - i only got about a quarter way through his iso, so i'll have to finish it tomorrow, sorry.i still think his targetted attack on TheAd was out of place...i'm leaving here in just a few so i will only have phone access until tomorrow...tomorrow should be light so i should be able to get some decent content on...

Ok. Looking forward to seeing a follow up here.

Slaandar's reaction to ThaD's vote is ridiculous, and this accusation is one of the most contrived things I have ever read.

So, we can assume beck is a town read yet he does not use becks logic to find scum pushing the beck wagon, which is odd, truely, looking for any reason to get your vote on me first eh?

Good man. Now lets turn this sentiment in to a vote, ey?

But thad slandaar drama is interesting keep it goin

If you want to keep it going vote slandaar. Trust.

@ slandaar - I was the first person to bring up that somebody on funky's wagon was scum here - http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p3523440

and than 5 posts later TheAd says the people I chose he disagree with and chose numbers 3, 4, and 5

so why are you grilling TheAd for picking somebody on that wagon, but not grilling me, since it was my suggestion to begin with?

ZING!
If you ever stop having tunnel vision with rev I would greatly appreciate a vote on slandaar.

I disagree that lurkers are much easier to lynch. Lurkers are much harder than active people to lynch imo.

Depends on the game but this is strangely true a lot of the time.

- page 34 -

Like iamausername's big post. I agree with a lot of his reads and it makes me feel better about him after him not doing much so far. But I am looking forward to him coming back so he can explain this:

Gonna run out of time if I don't rush some of these, so:

Town.

Ok. Up to page 35. Leaving it there for tonight.

[Slandaar]

No again. He's not been sniping he's been trolling.

Who thinks Funky has been Trolling?

I feel like the scum is sitting back and sniping. In any case it's what I'd do as scum.

What has funky been doing exactly? yeah sitting back and sniping (bussing) so, how did you get this magical funky is town read? because his wagon was going too well? but wait a second, wasnt funky doing exactly what you think the scum are? so the votes should be vindicated from your standpoint surely?

No, basically. Who's he bussing btw? I thought you said I knew funky was town?

Why was there no explanation of the town read?

This response doesn't even make sense, 'thought I knew funky was town' makes perfect sense with what I said.

[Slandaar]

well I feel that he's about equal scumminess with pops

Why?

[funkybike1]

If nothing makes sense, then everything is nothing and the result is nonsense.

UNVOTE:

[Revenus]

Don't ever try to sound intelligent again funkybike, it's not working out for you very well.

[Beck]

Don't ever try to sound intelligent again funkybike, it's not working out for you very well.

Pot calling the kettle black IMO.

[funkybike1]

I just unvoted you and THAT's what you say?

[ZeL1nK]

OK. My schedule has been fucked. Catching up now. 28 pages behind, so will be a while.

[sorgster]

@Beck-says the other pot
@funky-Just because you unvoted someone does not mean they'll be friendly,etc to you.

[theamatuer]

well I feel that he's about equal scumminess with pops

Why?

Pops tries to stifle down softclaiming altogether along with hypocrisy.
SV is obnoxious, and claims to have found all the scum at d1. He also claims a person is scummy while refusing to tell us the reason.
So yeah

[Beck]

@Beck-says the other pot
@funky-Just because you unvoted someone does not mean they'll be friendly,etc to you.

Says yet another pot.

Now we need the king pot SV to chime in

[Revenus]

I just unvoted you and THAT's what you say?

What? Should I be thanking you for making a decision that you should have made a long time ago?