So.. a couple quick thoughts!
Obviously you guys caught on to the setup.. though it was not the Meyers-Briggs test that I modeled it after, but the closely related
Keirsey Temperament Sorter.
Spyrex played a big hand in helping me with the actual role setup.
I wanted a game that had A LOT of night actions, but not a lot of follow-the-role opportunities. I wanted to foster a lot of discussion about the setup, and yes, Haylen was spot-on... all of the roles were from the "Rational" subgroup.
We were initially afraid it would be overpowered for the town, which is why we added in the Ninja role. Incidentally, it was never really used.. and Peregrine proved to be above suspicion most of the game.
There WAS a psychiatrist with no SK.
There WERE double roles.. two town watchers, and opposing name-cops
And we were very pleased with the amount of tail-chasing this inspired.
I DO want to give big props to a couple players:
a) kanye for playing in character <3
b) Haylen. Both of her night actions targeted scum, and she called the setup.
c) Parama and Peregrine.
-Although I was worried sick that this ended in a scum win due to a setup flaw... I have decided that these two guys simply manhandled this town. They never needed the 'ninja' role, and Parama's early play really smoothed out the rest of the game for him. I am not sure how Pere stayed off the burner.. but he certainly did.
And I welcome any and all modding/setup feedback. This is only my second time, and my first time with my own theme.