Animal Rescue: petsPick (Game Over!)

[Llamarble]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

[Amrun]

I believe Llamarble's claim. I think if he were fakeclaiming, he would have done it with more cognizance about how strange the claim was, in regards to his previously published reads.

Ghostlin wagon is still a go.

[Vi]

I believe Llamarble's claim. I think if he were fakeclaiming, he would have done it with more cognizance about how strange the claim was, in regards to his previously published reads.

How much cognizance do you think Llamarble has had about anything up until this point?

Of course, the jason wagon being made up of currently inactive people isn't helping me get him lynched as my vocal-ness isn't doing much so tonight

Your vocal-ness?

[Vi]

I don't mind and/or would join a Ghostlin wagon but would prefer a wagon on the people voting jason.

[Amrun]

How much cognizance do you think Llamarble has had about anything up until this point?

Fair point, and I'm not SLAMDUNKTOWN on Llamarble, but I'd prefer not to lynch him today.

Ghostlin is a much better lynch.

[glowball]

Can someone tell me why we aren't lynching Jason?

[Vi]

His wagon is full of scum and pushed with b.s.. But you would know that.

[zoraster]

Day 2

Amrun ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Cogito Ergo Sum ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Debonair Danny DiPietro ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Ghostlin ( 4 )

Kublai Khan,

Llamarble,

Amrun,

Cogito Ergo Sum,

[/color]

(L - 4 )

glowball ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

JasonT1981 ( 3 )

glowball,

Debonair Danny DiPietro,

xvart,

[/color]

(L - 5 )

Kublai Khan ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Llamarble ( 5 )

JasonT1981,

Vi,

VP Baltar,

Ghostlin,

Quilford,

[/color]

(L - 3 )

Quilford ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Sotty7 ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Untrod Tripod ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Vi ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

VP Baltar ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

xvart ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 8 )

No Lynch ( 0 )

Not Voting ( 3 )

Untrod Tripod, Roxi, Sotty7,

Total Votes ( 15 )

Needed to Lynch [ 8 ]

Deadline: Nov. 28th at 20:00 EST

[Ghostlin]

Mod: Announcing V/LA Thanksgiving weekend 24-27th Nov; my birthday and convention are happening that weekend. I may post, but it'll be spordaic.

[Kublai Khan]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Did Llamarble just claim Serial Killer?

[Kublai Khan]

VOTE: Llamarble

[jasonT1981]

Glowball ISO seems to show her sitting on sidelines, not wanting to give opinions and cheering on a lynch

WHY ISN'T LEW LYNCHED?!?!?!?!

Come on guys. Just lynch him and be happy!

but wait..

So you want... reads? I have none worth sharing at this point. I'll let you know when I do.

no reads eh?

I want Jason lynched.

now we have reads, after pressure... not explaining any of them... and giving a BS reason as to why

Okay I am not very good at explaining how my brain works but I will try my best to at least give you some indication of where I am at.

Scum:
Jason
CES
Xvart

On my radar:
Ghostlin
VP
Llamarble
Vi
Amrun

I am never really good at explaining how I get reads on people, which is probably why I'm so bad at this game but there are my thoughts.

Mmkay reasons why my lynch shouldn't even be considered today:

Scratch that! There's really only one main reason, my lynch won't help you with anything at all. When I flip town you'll have just as little information to go off of as you do now.

It's pretty obvious that Jason should be lynched, since he's scum and it gives us information. Llam COULD be lynched solely based on the information we'd get.

Fails to give reasons why she should not be lynched, appeals to emotion, then again tunnels me

Actually I takke back my previous statement, if we aren't going to lynch scum (Jason) then lynching me is fine.

for someone with no reads, Glowball really is lookign me lyched....oh look below.

Can someone tell me why we aren't lynching Jason?

Glowball has done NO scum hunting, repeated failures to answer questions... refuses to give reads, then shouts Why isn't (X) lynched.

Glowball... reasons for my lynch please, a full, thought out case. Bullet-points would be good. No crying because you are scum... A full case now please!

[jasonT1981]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Did Llamarble just claim Serial Killer?

As much as I believe a Llam lynch is good, I don't see how... it is more WIFOM... look only one kill, less than expected... VP was blocked so he must be scum.

Rubbish reasoning.

[jasonT1981]

Actually right now I am more comfortable with a Glowball lynch than Llam.. at least he is trying to play the game. She is just sitting on sidelines screaming for a lynch of anyone... D1 and D2.

unvote
vote: Glowball

[Ghostlin]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Did Llamarble just claim Serial Killer?

I don't get the reasoning here. Saying it's that 3rd part isn't a killing role and then pointing out VP was blocked....one of the things aren't necessarly like the others.

I also don't get why KK says 'serial killer' Llam here.

[jasonT1981]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Why are we still discussing stuff like this, there is still no evedience there is 3rd party, is there? right now, scum is the focus. All this is distracting from scum hunting with the WIFOM rubbish about less kills, means VP = scum because he was blocked.

For all we know, there is only one killing faction/role. Only way to establish that info is over longer terms. D2, with only one night for evedience is not worth looking at now... IF in future days there are more than one kill, then yes.. this needs looked at. But now, all the speculation is just that.

Right now, I am looking for scum.

[Ghostlin]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Why are we still discussing stuff like this, there is still no evedience there is 3rd party, is there? right now, scum is the focus. All this is distracting from scum hunting with the WIFOM rubbish about less kills, means VP = scum because he was blocked.

For all we know, there is only one killing faction/role. Only way to establish that info is over longer terms. D2, with only one night for evedience is not worth looking at now... IF in future days there are more than one kill, then yes.. this needs looked at. But now, all the speculation is just that.

Right now, I am looking for scum.

..Then you're saying you don't believe the Census Taker's Census?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

More likely is that he forgot.

Jason is towns.

[Kublai Khan]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Did Llamarble just claim Serial Killer?

I don't get the reasoning here. Saying it's that 3rd part isn't a killing role and then pointing out VP was blocked....one of the things aren't necessarly like the others.

I also don't get why KK says 'serial killer' Llam here.

If he's trying to argue that the third party isn't a killer, the how are the odds of VP Baltar being scum increased?

VP Baltar needs to actually weigh in on whether he knows if he was blocked or not to confirm if Llamarble is a tracker. If Llamarble is a tracker, then it's unlikely that he killed his tracking target. If VP Baltar wasn't roleblocked, then Llamarble didn't track xRECKONERx and instead is claiming he did in case a tracker (someone else) did track him targeting xRECKONERx.

[jasonT1981]

We're not sure the third party is a killing role or not.
But yeah, VP being blocked on a night where there weren't as many kills as expected increases the odds he's scum.

Why are we still discussing stuff like this, there is still no evedience there is 3rd party, is there? right now, scum is the focus. All this is distracting from scum hunting with the WIFOM rubbish about less kills, means VP = scum because he was blocked.

For all we know, there is only one killing faction/role. Only way to establish that info is over longer terms. D2, with only one night for evedience is not worth looking at now... IF in future days there are more than one kill, then yes.. this needs looked at. But now, all the speculation is just that.

Right now, I am looking for scum.

..Then you're saying you don't believe the Census Taker's Census?

Ah crap, yes sorry....

[glowball]

Actually right now I am more comfortable with a Glowball lynch than Llam.. at least he is trying to play the game. She is just sitting on sidelines screaming for a lynch of anyone... D1 and D2.

unvote
vote: Glowball

Actually I don't want ANYONE lynched. I want YOU lynched. If that quote of nothingness on this page is a "case"... no I won't be making one of those. If I actually sit down and go through all of your posts to make a case it will be when I have time. No one pressured me for my reads, in fact a wagon hasn't even ever been formed against me. I don't like to share all of my thoughts because frankly I can't always explain them. There's a tone to your posts, there are your actions towards other players and vice versa. It's something that I think takes a lot of time to explain and I prefer to let the chips fall before I go all in.

[jasonT1981]

OK, yes looking back I am wrong, I forgot Quilford took a census.

Still though, the VP was blocked, there was not as many kills as 'expected' therefor VP is scum... is just pure crazy.

though, LLam, how do you know there were less kills than expected to be? it is complete WIFOM and something I would expect from scum to parade out there.

I believe Glowball is scum for her cheerleading on lynches, and LLam is scum partly due to him trying to add confusion to the town.

[jasonT1981]

Actually right now I am more comfortable with a Glowball lynch than Llam.. at least he is trying to play the game. She is just sitting on sidelines screaming for a lynch of anyone... D1 and D2.

unvote
vote: Glowball

Actually I don't want ANYONE lynched. I want YOU lynched.

If that quote of nothingness on this page is a "case"... no I won't be making one of those. If I actually sit down and go through all of your posts to make a case it will be when I have time. No one pressured me for my reads, in fact a wagon hasn't even ever been formed against me.

I don't like to share all of my thoughts because frankly I can't always explain them

. There's a tone to your posts, there are your actions towards other players and vice versa.

It's something that I think takes a lot of time to explain and I prefer to let the chips fall before I go all in.

bold red: in other words, fence sit and wait for a wagon to form, and jump on.
bold blue: Again, just shouting for a lynch without any reasoning to anything. You did the same for Lew on D1.
bold green: then you need to try harder. If you really want me lynched, you sure as hell better do some explaining and if you are not going to do that, then you are not going to get me lynched.

[glowball]

Actually right now I am more comfortable with a Glowball lynch than Llam.. at least he is trying to play the game. She is just sitting on sidelines screaming for a lynch of anyone... D1 and D2.

unvote
vote: Glowball

Actually I don't want ANYONE lynched. I want YOU lynched.

If that quote of nothingness on this page is a "case"... no I won't be making one of those. If I actually sit down and go through all of your posts to make a case it will be when I have time. No one pressured me for my reads, in fact a wagon hasn't even ever been formed against me.

I don't like to share all of my thoughts because frankly I can't always explain them

. There's a tone to your posts, there are your actions towards other players and vice versa.

It's something that I think takes a lot of time to explain and I prefer to let the chips fall before I go all in.

bold red: in other words, fence sit and wait for a wagon to form, and jump on.
bold blue: Again, just shouting for a lynch without any reasoning to anything. You did the same for Lew on D1.
bold green: then you need to try harder. If you really want me lynched, you sure as hell better do some explaining and if you are not going to do that, then you are not going to get me lynched.

I'm not getting you lynched today whether I form a case or not.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

If he's trying to argue that the third party isn't a killer, the how are the odds of VP Baltar being scum increased?

Third party being a killing role need merely be a possibility for the logic to work. The reasoning is sound; the conclusion just isn't nearly as strong as you guys are making it out to be.