Mafia 48: Himalayan Mafia - Game over!

[Yosarian2]

If you cannot relate to the apathy feeling that I'm referring to, then you may be the remaining scum.

I've got to say, throwing a backhanded half-way "if you don't understand, then perhaps YOU are scum" OMGUS accusation at me for attacking you dosn't make me any less inclined to suspect you.

That being said, my primary reason for suspicion was not the fact you didn't defend yourself, it's your scummy looking voting record, and the fact that you were unable to commit to any other people seeming good to you other then Fritzer; considering how many scum lynches we've had, there's got to be SOMEONE else who seems townie to you, right?

[Lloyd]

there's got to be SOMEONE else who seems townie to you, right?

You are incorrect.

Fritzler is the only one who seems townie to me, as listed in my GG / BG / No read list earlier.

[MrBuddyLee]

My suspicions and reasoning behind them:

CES - Bad voting history (Fuldu, fritzler, pooky, RA, cesspit, neongrey), no interest in finding scum, lurking as a replacement.

creampuff - Made strange posts attacking jamessparrow, fuldu and lordy recently which come across as canned.
twomz - Showed a lack of seriousness and excessive certainty in midgame but has sobered and appears to be hunting scum.
lordy - His predecessor James gave no major scum vibes, but lordy has been bizarre and suspects only creampuff, and gives no original reasons.
lloyd - His asking questions of people makes it appear that he's scumhunting. His shift from voting Fritz to Fritz as his only GG was unexplained.

fritzler - Led the charge on DG and Flay. Flay's attacks on him were so over the top, I doubt he's scum.
Yosarian2 and rikimaru - The tone of their posts is pro-town and I agree for the most part with the people they voted for and the reasons why. They demonstrate consistency and no sense of manipulation.

vote: CES.

As of now I'd switch my vote to creampuff over lordy if it comes down to deciding between those two.

[Norinel]

About 55 hours to deadline.

Vote Count:

lordy- 3 (Lloyd, Fritzler, creampuffeater)
Creampuffeater- 2 (Twomz, lordy)
Lloyd- 1 (Yosarian2)
Cogito Ergo Sum- 1 (MrBuddyLee)

Not voting: Everyone else

5 to lynch, 3 at deadline.

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: CPE

vote for him too mbl

git er done

[MrBuddyLee]

Anyway, I need to finish reading the thread and we need to ask ourselves why Fuldu got killed. I mean, he wasn't voting for Mr. Flay.

that's your entire contribution for today. weak, particularly for a mountainous game.

[Yosarian2]

Fine. Looks like no one else wants a lloyd lynch today, and the deadline's in about a day. I guess I might as well go to my #2 suspect for now.

unvote:lloyd

vote:lordy

[lordy]

So you guys are giving me no chance?

Since basically this is a ll townie game, you have nothing to lose, except a townie. But before we finish this game off, I want to read it again and post my suspisions. Since I am basically lynched at deadline unless you guys want to be kind. let me finish my work here.

While some evil scum is smiling sweetly at himself for making a scapegoat out of me, that is.

[lordy]

Could any townie unvote me and vote for cream puff instead?

I'm not about to give up living yet. Im at even votes with a potential scum, and I want to lynch scum today instead having to fight with you guys all again tommorrow?

Reasons why I think I'll live until tomorrow if I dont die today?
Simple. Because I screwed up today. And if we lynch creampuff and he turns up as a screwed up townie, and prove my theory against him wrong, its my turn at the gullotine tommorrow. And the scum would be happy watching all the lordy hate and playing along. I thought I found scum when I chanced upon fritzs and lee, but now I'm thinking otherwise because the town has told me otherwise, and due to this I'm pure confused now. This why I'm being very direct of my vote against cream. He is the only scummy beacon tower in this sea that resulted after confusing myself.

WHY AM I VOTING FOR CREAM.
It's simple. He has been quick to jump on tidus, right before dripping goofball did. He did not vote for DG on day two, even though she was exposed scum. He went quiet from day 3 onwards until day 6, where he and flay voted for each other. This could be distancing, as the last scum would then on be left on his own now. And on this day, he cast the lynching at dealine vote on me, until fritz unvoted, and yos came on me.

WHY AM I CLEARING FRITZ & LEE NOW?
Another simple one. It's called re-reading. At day one I saw how DG attempted to start a discussion on who would be the likely recuit for the scum, picking out fritz and hezlucky. Yet DG simply pressured hez and ignored fritz.(im rather confused about this part, but for now I'm taking this as a point for fritzs rather than against. Furthermore, with Mr Flay's pounding on fritz the last few days, I'm inclined to think fritz id town.

As for the Lees, it's simple. Mafia wouldn't normally provide in depth analysises for the town, and even if they do, they would normally try to mislead the town with their analysises. I havent seen misleading in his posts yet, and thats why I'm laying off him at the momment.

Please guy, I'm begging you guys to let me stay another day. Night will reveal alot of infomation that could help very well on who is scum for the town. I want to stay on because now I believe I can help the town, and perhaps drag myself out of my confusion.

My vote's staying. I hope your's goes off me.

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: lordy

[Twomz]

Yeah, I'm pretty sure Lordy is the last scum. "Just one more day" ploys are usually mafia attempts to get one more NK in (kinda pointless if you're the last scum but w/e). Also, it wasn't clear that DG was scum, Fritz just pushed it (i'm guessing on a hunch or a minor tell) because he's Fritz.

[Norinel]

Vote Count:

lordy- 4 (Lloyd, creampuffeater, Yosarian2, Fritzler)
Creampuffeater- 2 (Twomz, lordy)
Cogito Ergo Sum- 1 (MrBuddyLee)

Not voting: Cogito Ergo Sum, Dead Rikimaru

5 to lynch, 3 at deadline.

Day 7:

They all thought lordy's lording over everyone else was a surefire sign of him being the last of the villains. Too bad it wasn't.

lordy (Townie) - lynched Day 7.

It is now Night 7, send choice.

I need to replace CES; deadline 48 hours unless finding a replacement takes longer.

[Norinel]

Night 7

:

Dead Rikimaru is as dead as his name would suggest. Have some numbers:

Townies alive: 6
Mafia alive: 1

Mafia lynches to town win: 1
Town lynches to mafia win: 3
Chance of town win given random lynch: 54.4%

Dead Rikimaru (Townie) - killed Night 7

It is now Day 8, 7 alive means 4 to lynch. Deadline 9 days, July 17.

[Twomz]

vote: CPE

[Lloyd]

Vote: creampuffeater

My suspicion of him from yesterday stands.

[Yosarian2]

vote:lloyd

I, personally, would be rather surprised if CPE turns out to be scum, especally considering the way Flay was trying to get broomhead lynched earlier in the game. Now, he could still be scum, he's not someone I consider, but I think a lloyd lynch today is a better bet.

[MrBuddyLee]

I, personally, would be rather surprised if CPE turns out to be scum, especally considering the way Flay was trying to get broomhead lynched earlier in the game.

Can you elaborate on this please?

[Lloyd]

MBL, I think Yosarian2 is confusing CPE with CES.

[Yosarian2]

(sigh) Yes, yes I was. Darn TLA's. Let me see what I have about CPE.

[Yosarian2]

Hmm...ok.

CreamPuffEater has been posting very little the game, only about once a week for much of it, which make me suspicious of him as a semi-lurker. However, his voting record is quite good; he was the 6'th vote on the day 1 dripping goofball wagon, the 2'nd vote on the day 1 tidus wagon, and he voted for flay twice, including on the day he was lynched. I haven't ruled him out as possible scum, but it dosn't seem to me all that likely at this point.

[MrBuddyLee]

creampuff's voting history: DG, tidus, fritz, neongrey, cesspit, Flay, lordy

broomhead/CES's: Fuldu, Fritz, Pooky, RA, cesspit, neongrey, lloyd, an inconsequential hammer on Flay, no vote at all yesterday

If you assume creampuff is scum, he's been 3/7 on votes.
If you assume broomhead's scum, he's been 1/8 on votes, and that one was so late it shouldn't be counted.

Vote: CES.

His voting record's been bad. His last post was two weeks ago. Before that, broomhead was a non-entity.

Ultimately, creampuff's strange remarks and reasons for voting haven't been nearly as bad as broomhead/CES's history.

[Norinel]

Vote Count:

creampuffeater- 2 (Twomz, Lloyd)
Lloyd- 1 (Yosarian2)
Cogito Ergo Sum- 1 (MrBuddyLee)

Not voting (3): CES, Fritzler, creampuffeater

4 to lynch.

[Yosarian2]

creampuff's voting history: DG, tidus, fritz, neongrey, cesspit, Flay, lordy

broomhead/CES's: Fuldu, Fritz, Pooky, RA, cesspit, neongrey, lloyd, an inconsequential hammer on Flay, no vote at all yesterday

If you assume creampuff is scum, he's been 3/7 on votes.
If you assume broomhead's scum, he's been 1/8 on votes, and that one was so late it shouldn't be counted.

Vote: CES.

His voting record's been bad. His last post was two weeks ago. Before that, broomhead was a non-entity.

Ultimately, creampuff's strange remarks and reasons for voting haven't been nearly as bad as broomhead/CES's history.

Well, that does make sense. Is there a reason you're not considering Lloyd right now, though? If we're looking at voting records, his is the worst of any one who is still alive.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I apologize to the town for my inactivity.

I personally think there might be much to gain from nightkill analysis at this point. It may give us significant insight into the workings of the mind of our final scum. I also personally think Lloyd is our final scum. He's also not the kind of guy I see throwing his scumbuddies under the bus, although I could be mistaken in that regard.

Vote: Lloyd

[creampuffeater]

I think that the scum is either CES (broomhead had a bad voting record, and you havent improved it much) or Lloyd (constant attack on me, and just is acting very scummy.

Vote: CES

. I think that CES is the scummiest person right now, followed by lloyd, and then probably twomz.