Mafia 48: Himalayan Mafia - Game over!

[creampuffeater]

Ok... after all this, I now think the scum is twomz. That second vote is very scummy, even though you said you would put it on. so

Vote: Twomz

[Norinel]

5 days to deadline.

Vote Count

creampuffeater- 2 (Cogito Ergo Sum, Twomz)
Twomz- 1 (creampuffeater)

Not voting (2): MrBuddyLee, Yosarian2

3 to lynch.

[MrBuddyLee]

I'm rereading the thread. Back with a vote and comments tonight or tomorrow.

[Fritzler]

FRITZ IS DEAD NOES.... personally I think scum is CES, but it could be twomz.

damn right its noes

g'luck guys

[Yosarian2]

Ok... after all this, I now think the scum is twomz. That second vote is very scummy, even though you said you would put it on. so

Vote: Twomz

Um, why? He went into great detail yesterday about why he thought you were sucmmy. He might be right, or he might be wrong, but you think he's scummy because he's voting for you after having several long posts saying in great detail he thought you were suspicious?

[Norinel]

No vote changes. Mathcam will be finishing up the modding when I'm gone starting Thursday, so he'll announce the exact time for the deadline.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Somone hammah.

[Yosarian2]

(shrug) I'm thinking about it, but we have a few days left before deadline, I'd like to have a little more discussion first.

CES, I would think you would especally want more discussion, as it sounds like some people wanted to lynch you next if CPE turns out to not be scum.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I'm not worried about that, as I'm pretty sure cpe is the final scum. I don't feel like going through a lot of trouble for nothing.

Also, I'll be gone Tuesday-Saturdayish, so I'd rather just finish it.

[Twomz]

While he's wording may be scummy, i think CES is right for now. If CPE isn't the final scum, I want us to look at ALL of the remaining players, not just CES. If MBL or Yos turn up to be the last scum... well, they've fooled me so far . It's still possible, and we need to make sure we double check everyone. But, there is no reason to do so today. Just remember not to vote right off the bat tomorrow, and to wait til you KNOW who you're voting for is the last one.

[Yosarian2]

(shrug) Perhaps; still, I see no reason to rush this.

I'm still waiting to hear from CPE; why are you voting for Twomz?

[Twomz]

Ok... after all this, I now think the scum is twomz. That second vote is very scummy, even though you said you would put it on. so Vote: Twomz

This was the reason he gave... which to me is OMGUS... but w/e.

[MrBuddyLee]

Yosarian (9th on tidus, 4th on DGB, 1st on Flay)

he's read the thread with a critical eye, noticed helpful details that no one else did, and lurker hunted but not to excess. Cautious but mostly correct play.

He wasn't the catalyst of the tidus lynch but made a good post attacking some bad tidus logic. DGB attacked him in a way I don't see scum attacking scum. Hit Flay somewhat hard when Flay wasn't a top target.

Twomz (6th on tidus, 6th on DGB, 4th on Flay)

has posted quite a bit, and a fair amount of good analysis. Gave stated reasons for a few votes as other people's logic, which I'd generally rather see replaced by his own opinions. Until Flay died, based some of his analysis on who a likely recruit would have been.

Even though he was wrong on Cesspit, I agreed with that push and found Twomz pro-town for it. He made a good pbpa post recently about CPE which looks solid.

I find several of his posts scummy style-wise but his reasoning pretty sound.

creampuffeater (3rd on tidus, not on DGB, 3rd on Flay)

Decent voting record, his stated reasons for suspicions started out pretty good but have gotten progressively worse.

cpe's reasons for finding DG, Cess, Fritz, neongrey, lordy and broomhead suspicious were sound. His suspicions of JamesSparrow, lloyd and twomz have been strange and OMGUSish. He was good on tidus, incorrect on DGB but for conceivably ok reasons, and strangely wishy-washy on Flay.


CES/broomhead (not on tidus, not on dgb, 6th on Flay)

broomhead was very thin on analysis. CES has been better.

CES provided nightkill analysis which points to creampuff. broomhead didn't mention many people, but never questioned or mentioned tidus, DGB or Flay until after they were each lynched. CES has made some effort to remedy, but overall broomhead/CES's contribution has been the worst in the game.

vote: CES

creampuff: Why Twomz and not CES? Your Twomz vote is awfully OMGUS.

Twomz: Why creampuff and not CES?

[Twomz]

I find CPE more likely to be scum than CES. But, if the town feels like we should lynch CES today instead of CPE I suppose that's ok. But I still think CPE is the last scum.

unvote, vote CES

.

I find it extremely unlikely that MBL or Yos are mafiasos... so it doesn't really matter (at least from my POV) what order we lynch them in.

If there are any last minute questions to ask before we finish off CES (or CPE) better ask them soon.

[Yosarian2]

Twomz: I'm not really liking this "oh, I don't care what order we lynch them in" thing you're doing. Makes me wonder if you're the scum, trying to set up a win for yourself. Perhaps not the most likely possibility, but it's worrying me. So who do you think is scummy, and why?

[Twomz]

CPE, reasons given already. But, it seems as though the majority of the town doesn't follow my train of thought on the situation. So, i'm taking the course of action that in my mind leads to the eventual lynch of CPE. The only other choices i have are to either Convince you or MBL that CPE is the last scum (if my summary of his posts didn't do that I dont' know what will) or to leave my vote on CPE til the deadline. I see no reason why we have to wait til the deadline... but I suppose you're right, there is no reason for me to try to set up lynches or wait for tomorrow to lynch CPE,

unvote, vote: creampuffeater

Now Yos, who do YOU think is scummy. I believe you're the only person who hasn't voted yet... and you're right, where is CPE? I know he's around because i've seen him in #mafia on IRC.

[creampuffeater]

My reason on twomz, is not really a OMGUS, but more of a why are u so completly bandwagoning that you arent looking at facts. Yes I do realise, that it seems like OMGUS, but he is acting a little to bloodthirsty for my liking. He also seems not to care who he lynches (well at least thats what i get from the back and forth of CES.) I think it might be CES, but he is not acting as bloodthirsty as twomz is. Sorry for being away, I was a little busy (i also forgot about the game for a day x_x)

[Yosarian2]

CPE, reasons given already. But, it seems as though the majority of the town doesn't follow my train of thought on the situation. So, i'm taking the course of action that in my mind leads to the eventual lynch of CPE. The only other choices i have are to either Convince you or MBL that CPE is the last scum (if my summary of his posts didn't do that I dont' know what will) or to leave my vote on CPE til the deadline. I see no reason why we have to wait til the deadline... but I suppose you're right, there is no reason for me to try to set up lynches or wait for tomorrow to lynch CPE,

unvote, vote: creampuffeater

Now Yos, who do YOU think is scummy. I believe you're the only person who hasn't voted yet... and you're right, where is CPE? I know he's around because i've seen him in #mafia on IRC.

At this point, CES is probably my top suspect, followed (in some order) by CPE and you. I have a strong feeling MrBuddyLee is town.

[Norinel]

This is the last you'll see of me.

Vote Count

creampuffeater- 2 (Cogito Ergo Sum, Twomz)
Twomz- 1 (creampuffeater)
Cogito Ergo Sum- 1 (MrBuddyLee)

Not voting (1): Yosarian2

3 to lynch.

[creampuffeater]

Even though I really think twomz is scum, I am fine with a CES lynch

[Yosarian2]

I guess I'll go ahead and

vote:Congiot Ergo Sum

. Out of the three suspects, he has the worst voting record of any of them. The only point I had in his favor in my notes was that Flay attacked Broomhead pretty hard, but I know Flay is good at distancing himself from fellow scum, so that might not mean much.

[creampuffeater]

well... It seems that the CES is the lynch for today, and since I probably wont be able to get on again before the deadline, I might as well vote now

Unvote, Vote CES

I hope this is correct

[creampuffeater]

O and I would like to add, that on August 5th I am going on vacation, so I will need a replacement . so lets hope CES was the scum

[mathcam]

Official End-Of-Day Vote Count:

Cogito Ergo Sum- 3 (MrBuddyLee, Yosarian2, creampuffeater)
creampuffeater- 2 (Cogito Ergo Sum, Twomz)

And with that, CES (townie) has been lynched. Get those night choices in!

Cam

[mathcam]

Tonight's victim is Yosarian. With 3 alive, it takes

2 to lynch.

Cam