Mafia 48: Himalayan Mafia - Game over!

[creampuffeater]

well personally, I think the scum is Twomz, as MBL and Yosarian were the 2 people I thought were townies. Though I will not vote yet, to try and make sure that Twomz is the scum.

[Twomz]

Vote: Creampuffeater

I've been advocating his lynch for a while now, and I don't think MBL is scum, so it's the only logical conclusion.

MBL, I'm assuming the next that happens is CPE is going to vote me (OMGUS and last resort). Then it'll be up to you to decide. At the very least you have a 50% chance. *shrug*

[creampuffeater]

Might as well

Vote: Twomz

then. Yes, this is OMGUS, but it is getting the scum. As twomz said, you have a 50% chance of victory. (sidenote I am leaving Sat. for London/Paris, so try and hurry your decision a little bit so i can see if town wins

[MrBuddyLee]

Jeez, you both voted so quickly. Usually I'd think scum would vote quickly and the townie would take the time to ask both sides a few questions to try and trip them up. So I guess I can't use that as a deciding factor.

Creampuffeater had a pretty decent voting record all game and didn't really sound scummy to me. Twomz was somewhat flippant for a while but then got serious and started hunting for scum about halfway through.

Towards the end of the game I think you both acted pretty pro-town, so this is a tough decision. I'd take the time to ask some questions, but since CPE is leaving town soon, I think it's best to

vote: Twomz

and hope I caught the crafty scum.

Am I right? I'm thinking my chances here are slightly better than 50-50.

ps. A "well-played" to everyone regardless of the outcome, and a thanks to Mr. Flay, DGB and tidus for proving to be pretty damned good scum.

[Lloyd]

Since I think the game is now over, I'll comment and hopefully not get in trouble

I didn't think I could push for a second attempt ini lynching the Lees, even though I still found him / them somewhat suspicious.

After I was heavily questioned for my GG / BG list of only listing Fritzler as GG, I somewhat gave up on the game at that point, and started started suspecting Twomz.

After I died, I thought the last scum was Yosarian2, because he was pushing hard for my lynch.

Very recently, someone told me who the last scum really is; hehe.

Even though hindsight is usually close to 20-20:

In this game...A very risky bet by LmL to quit playing mafia if DGB wasn't scum seems too risky of a bet.

It became a ticket to ride the rest of the game to victory.

Good game scum.

[Twomz]

MBL... if you're scum, then you did a great job this game.... If you're town... WWHHHHYYYYY???? Either way the town is going to lose.

And I found out in the 2v2 tourny my friend and I signed up for, we're going against people from the clan that won 1rst 2nd AND 3rd place last year... We're boned.

I suppose it's a matter of waiting for the Mod now. Two bits of bad news in one 2 minute stretch .

[MrBuddyLee]

I think LML was betting his "mafia life in this game" only. He was willing to be lynched if DGB wasn't scum.

It sucks to get replacements in mountainous games because to some extent I think they're held less accountable for the actions of the person they replaced. Nevertheless, LML, DGB and Flay did a great job of confusing people and even tidus managed not to give away any partners with his actions.

Thanks for the fun guys--I enjoyed this game more than any of my other ones. Be rougher on the scum next time... even if you think they're town.

[creampuffeater]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TWOMZ WAS SCUM COMPLETLY IMO. O well, very nice playing MBL I thought you were deff town.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Nice Job Scum

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Lynching people while they're away for no good reason = bad.

[Thesp]

So was CPE the last scum? I'm confused.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

No, MBL was.

[Twomz]

I'm assuming from his speech and CPE's response that MBL was scum. Either way it doesn't matter because i'm really town so we lose no matter which one of them is scum.

[creampuffeater]

I was town... And isnt it obvois from what MBL said for him to be scum im sad over this game... I was so sure it was twomz.

[HezLucky]

Darn... after all I did catching scum for you guys Day One...

[Twomz]

That might have been the problem. We knocked out 2 of the scum early on, so there was no real way to connect them their scum buddies.

[vikingfan]

So who was the recruit and what was the rationale?

[Twomz]

Imo, most likely flay for exp, but you'll have to ask one of the scum for the real answer. Has anyone seen Norinel? I need closure .

[Thesp]

Norinel's out for 3 weeks, I think.

[mathcam]

MBL was indeed scum.

Mafia wins.

Cam

[mathcam]

And Mr. Flay was the initial scum recruit.

Cam

[Yosarian2]

Good game, all.

Heh...I was so proud of myself for figuring out Mr. Flay and DGB were scum, but LML totally pulled one over on me; I really thought he was a good guy. Well played, everyone.

[Twomz]

Indeed MBL/LML should get MVP scum.

I'm sorry town, but i'd said it the day before... if Yos or MBL were scum, then we were going to lose, because I wasn't getting a scummy vibe from either of them.

[Mr. Flay]

*laugh* Holy (&%^*$* - we made it??? Unreal - major props to MBL/LML for ballsy playing.

Town did a good job, actually, especially knocking us down 1-2 in the first two days. But as somebody else said, that created a lot of confusion later on as to who could be paired together. If it hadn't been for Fritzler's "confirmation", my ploy to attack him relentlessly might have gotten him lynched, too.

I was running WIFOM the entire game, of course....when Norinel sent me the PM that I'd been recruited, I thought "well, crap, that's too obvious..."

Good game, everybody, but especially the Lees!

[DrippingGoofball]

I was actually pretty annoyed at LML who STARTED a wagon a me for no reason, when I was flying well under the radar.

What was up with that? I wanted to throttle him.

After Lloyd's brillant and correct analysis that uncovered LML as scum, I was willing to throw LML under the bus.

How on Earth did I end up being lynched?

Easy! When I post, whether I am town, doctor, cop, scum... I just have to post and I get lynched. No one ever thinks I'm Town, haha! I'm a free lynch for the scum if I am Town. But this time I WAS scum...

So I tried to use the opportunity to throw as many names in my posts as possible to create mayhem while posting my way to being lynched.

MBL - you were awesome!

I don't know how you pulled it off, but you did a fantastic job, you were one against many.