Open 9 - Basic Twelve Player (Game Over!) - before 400

[Twito]

Not difficult decision, not at all.

Vote: Masterchief

Lets try to lynch him on first page shall we.
Since he is scum ya know.. or if he's not he is atleast useless for the town ..or more likely threat to the town.

[Twito]

Not difficult decision, not at all.

Vote: Masterchief

Lets try to lynch him on first page shall we.
Since he is scum ya know.. or if he's not he is atleast useless for the town ..or more likely threat to the town.

Why do you do this in every game?

Vote: Twito

OMGUS

[Twito]

It's funny how MC always acts like scum AND turns out to be scum.

[Twito]

Damn it, it's only page one and already Twito's convinced me that he's town.

unvote

my brother in alcohol abuse,

vote:Battle Mage

for the badlogic. I would think, occasionally, that Lowell votes for scum.

I have no idea how I did it. You must teach me to do it when I'm scum!

Vote: Battle Mage

I agree about the bad logic, but also there was something about this, the very first words of the first post of the day:

lol with a doctor called Sage, its hardly surprising that the Mafia got him lol.

I can just about see Battle Mage if he was scum saying to the others "hey, wouldn't it be funny if the doctor was Sage" and them agreeing, what the hell, may as well go for it, and then BM being unable to resist this post, a kind of coded "omg guys it worked how cool is that???"

Unbeatable logic. If that is indeed true I will laugh so bad

For a while I've listed this game as boring coz other games require my attention.

[Twito]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

I just watched a newbie vote protown just to see how the protown responds.
I find this particular vote as scummy.

If Battle Mages vote was serious he looks scummy to me. I still have the feeling it wasn't. I mean c'moon who seriously thinks MC could be town?

[Twito]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

I just watched a newbie vote protown just to see how the protown responds.
I find this particular vote as scummy.

If Battle Mages vote was serious he looks scummy to me. I still have the feeling it wasn't. I mean c'moon who seriously thinks MC could be town?

I want to see what Battlemage responds. WE can't be sure if Battlemage is protown or not, and right now he is our best lead.

And that's so not truth. We have MC remember. That's Masterchief. M-a-s-t-e-r-C-h-i-e-f. You just have to type vote before the two letter M and C. It's pretty simply.

And now I'm leading a newbie. But to the right direction. Unless BattleMage is also right direction.

Or maybe the newbies have an alliance and they are trying to get me to lead them so that they can later easily lynch me.

Sometimes I wonder..

[Twito]

Twito,
Your willingness to lynch someone merely based on a vendetta against that person is annoying. Please stop it. Yes, he is a real idiot - we just lynched in in Space Monkey mafia because he claimed mafia. And wasn't. But still, we've got to be smart about this game - we've already lost our doctor, we're looking at pretty bad odds here.

But he is threat to the town no matter of his allignment..
I will think about it when something else catches my eye. I want to lynch him but that doesn't seperate me from following the game otherwise and possibly lynching someone else in the end.

[Twito]

Obligatory Vote:Twito

The same could be said about you. Something about a newbie game that Thok only didn't count to ruin the game....

<.<

Not really. I do read all the post unlike him and I participate. I do joke around however which can be coincidered equally dangerous I guess. I don't think so and there appear to be others too. I find you comparing me to MC very insulting.

And I really like that newbie game. I asked him before voting(not waiting for answer though.. make more clear rules will you. Just add "Votes without first unvoting count/don't count".) whether voting counts without unvoting. I was never planning on hammering myself thank you very much. Also it's on going game so it shouldn't be referred to too much.

[Twito]

Why the heck did you claim on page 2?

Secound that.
We were basicly still random voting and you weren't that close to lynch. I mean c'moon you were at 3 and it's 6 to lynch.

[Twito]

"look, I'm not scum, I don't know how else to say it."

Then again newbies say the same thing as their only defence no matter of their real allignment.. they always try to fool me!

[Twito]

I can just about see Battle Mage if he was scum saying to the others "hey, wouldn't it be funny if the doctor was Sage" and them agreeing, what the hell, may as well go for it, and then BM being unable to resist this post, a kind of coded "omg guys it worked how cool is that???"

.......?

unvote, Vote:Ripley

And me stupid replied to the same comment with a smiley face.. I guess you can also vote based on it..

[Twito]

I think I'm beginning to believe that Battlemage is not scum. Even though, he did claim too early.

Unvote: Battlemage

I don't think any one esle is that scummy.

Also, I didn't jump on the bandwagon, because of nothing, I thought, Ripley's post was good, and argeed with it.

You though Ripleys post was good and you agreed with it?

Vote: Fircoal

[Twito]

Now that you look at it? And you already voted based on it. C'moon!

[Twito]

WEll I see that there wasn't any difference, about the other posts but 1 thing added that really didn't add much importance. I argeed about the bad logic, and thought he was the scummiest so that's why I made my vote that way.

I don't agree with your reasons for bandwagoning but I'm not sure yet whether that makes you scum or not.

[Twito]

Twito... if you think Fircoal is scummy for Ripley's reasoning.... why aren't you voting Ripley? If that's why you're voting Fircoal, shouldn't Ripley be your manin vote, and watch Fircoal?

IGMEOY:Twito

Ripleys reasoning was so funny that I can't vote the poor guy for making me laugh. Fircoal however stated that was a GOOD REASONING.
Then again I guess Ripley wasn't joking but he was serious about it so they are both scummy. Fircoal for following horrible reason to wagon and Ripley for making the horrible reason.

Unvote

for now I don't know where to move my vote or whether to keep it were it is. Gotta think.

lol if ur going to accuse me, at least accuse me of something i have done.
When did i accuse Fircoal of bad logic? If i remember rightly, it was the other way around...
Your logic however IS flawed, because u dont seem to realise that not everyone in the Mafia Game tells the truth. I have claimed i am a townie, but the Mafia doesnt know if that is true. I could just be saving my arse from a lynching.

Unvote, Vote SpectrumVoid

Making simple mistakes, and being a general jerk=scum

vote: Battle Mage

That's just pure OMGUS vote.

O

h

M

y

G

od

Y

ou

S

uck.
Your voting him based only on him voting you.

He didn't say your claiming was bad logic it had nothing to do with the claiming.

[Twito]

Twito... if you think Fircoal is scummy for Ripley's reasoning.... why aren't you voting Ripley? If that's why you're voting Fircoal, shouldn't Ripley be your manin vote, and watch Fircoal?

IGMEOY:Twito

Ripleys reasoning was so funny that I can't vote the poor guy for making me laugh. Fircoal however stated that was a GOOD REASONING.
Then again I guess Ripley wasn't joking but he was serious about it so they are both scummy. Fircoal for following horrible reason to wagon and Ripley for making the horrible reason.

Unvote

for now I don't know where to move my vote or whether to keep it were it is. Gotta think.

lol if ur going to accuse me, at least accuse me of something i have done.
When did i accuse Fircoal of bad logic? If i remember rightly, it was the other way around...
Your logic however IS flawed, because u dont seem to realise that not everyone in the Mafia Game tells the truth. I have claimed i am a townie, but the Mafia doesnt know if that is true. I could just be saving my arse from a lynching.

Unvote, Vote SpectrumVoid

Making simple mistakes, and being a general jerk=scum

vote: Battle Mage

That's just pure OMGUS vote.

O

h

M

y

G

od

Y

ou

S

uck.
Your voting him based only on him voting you.

He didn't say your claiming was bad logic it had nothing to do with the claiming.

(fixed the quoting the first one looks bad)

[Twito]

an OMGUS vote?
smooth...
If ur gonna insult someone for no reason, dont bother trying to make urself look smart by inventing some stupid abbreviation.

http://mafiascum.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl/OMGUS
Read it please. I didn't invent it. I'm not insulting you. Take it easy.

[Twito]

Just though would be useful to explain it as I assumed not everyone here knows the term. I was right btw.

[Twito]

Ok BM so you lied? Are you really scum?

[Twito]

I'm also curious why SL FoS'd IH.

Other than that, I'm still pretty happy with my Battle Mage vote.

I feel like your going with the flow.

TCS: What is your opinion on this meta statement: "One Day 1 lynch is as good as any other."

That as far as I can tell, day one lynches are completely random anyway, unless a scum is completely stupid?

You are so so wrong.

May I ask why you quoted yourself for that AndrewS vote?

I know the answer but I let him answer himself.

[Twito]

Nevermind, I thought I had the last post of page four.

unvote, Vote:AndrewS

Agreeance with SV on this one.

Also, Spectrumvoid is a laydee(Lady). Gender Icons help. <3 SV

I knew it butbutbut..
I just seem to forget..
I'm just gonna call everyone as they were ladies.

[Twito]

Twito: is this the behavior you expected from Masterchief when you said he would be useless? We've had one early vote and since then nothing at all. I think somebody also said he claimed Mafia in another game where he was pro town? If he's really not going to make any useful contribution maybe we should consider lynching him. Maybe he's scum. If not, he's more or less guaranteed not to be nightkilled, scum never kill off useless people, so unless we lynch him we're stuck with him forever. And it'll be more and more of a pain having someone around who isn't helping, when there are fewer of us.

Exactly.
Yes this is what I meant when I said he will be useless. He should be either lynched or replaced.
He will never read the thread and even if he happens to post the post is likely to have no content at all. Good luck finding even one contentful post he has made, ever.
And it's truth that he claimed mafia when he was protown on other game.

[Twito]

Mod:

Can we get a prod on MC and if he doesn't answer it, lets say 48 hours a replacement?

[Twito]

ShadowLurker I love your picture posts if you don't keep posting them I will.. hell there is nothing I can do... CRY!

[Twito]

And wait for one of two things to happen: Either MC posts or his replacement posts.

If MC answers the prod we really have to lynch him.

[Twito]

I think MC has generally disappeared. I've been prodding him elsewhere too, and I'm about to look for a replacement.

Please do that <3

[Twito]

Masterchief has not picked up his prod. I'll look for a replacement. That doesn't mean that you guys can't play in the meantime

Paaaaartyyy!!!

[Twito]

Awesome with the fast replacement. Akbar replaces Masterchief. Everyone give him a warm welcome

*gives Akbar warm welcome*

And I'm not sure if this is important, but Twito and Lowell have the exact same voting pattern. Both picked MC (errr me I guess), then Fircoal, then SV. Kinda like partners would do. </shrug>

Actually my vote is still on Fircoal and I've never voted SV.

So our three scum are AndrewS, IH, and TCS, which one of them should we lynch first?

I guess that doesn't matter if all of them are scum.

So being confident about the Mafia makes me Mafia? What wonderful logic skills.

Mafia would be confident about ones scumbuddys being mafia.

I need to go over the thread instead of being retarded.

You only have those 2 options?

Well, let me throw out my defense, since I'm 2 from lynch and recent history has shown me that hammers can seem to be unpredictable.

Yeah well I am in this game indeed. But it's almost predictable that I will hammer if you end up at lynch -1. No I won't I did it once and no need to do it again don't worry.. or if you want you can worry..

[Twito]

And I have 3 scumbuddies?

Hell if you have another one just say so, you are the one that knows it.

[Twito]

Sorry about that Twito, I was looking at post 63.

So thats just you quoting BM doing a vote on SV then??

That's not your vote?

Yes it's just me failing my quote on BM, it's not my vote. Mod noticed this in the votecount.

[Twito]

Unless you think that him claiming vanilla townie is really a "strong town tell," I don't see what would lead you to completely write him off.

He made some towntell which I'm too lazy to find myself and am waiting for him to point out. It obviously cannot be claiming vanilla townie are you fking stupid?

[Twito]

I obviously meant "..I think you are wrong about that" Instead of "..are you fking stupid"

[Twito]

Unless you think that him claiming vanilla townie is really a "strong town tell," I don't see what would lead you to completely write him off.

He made some towntell which I'm too lazy to find myself and am waiting for him to point out. It obviously cannot be claiming vanilla townie are you fking stupid?

My reference to his claim was sarcasm. Are you fucking stupid?

I've seen your play before. I know you are capable of doing something that stupid..I mean something that I think is wrong.. so first thing that comes to my mind is that you are doing it again.

[Twito]

Damn it, it's only page one and already Twito's convinced me that he's town.

(which seems surprisingly quick to me)

You are just jealous!

"Twito's convinced me that he is town" was mostly a joke.

Damn. You already got me thinking your that good at reading me.

I'm sold on Akbar, Andrew, and SL all being pro-town.

You forgot Twito. T-w-i-t-o.

particularly the ones that seem to be sucking up to the newbie players.

First they tell us to help out newbies and then they attack us for it.

[Twito]

Still rereading.

Ha! Lying scum! It's 8 pages doesn't take THAT long to re-read.

[Twito]

Also if Warming up to SV is a scumtell, then I must look scummy in every game I'm in with her. = )

Shooting down the argument instead of the messenger is a scumtell.

[Twito]

Ha! Lying scum! It's 8 pages doesn't take THAT long to re-read.

It does when I'm illiterate ;_;

Actually it does when I have other games to check on and keep getting distractions, like my 7 year old sister pulling on me, repeating my name every other second. = )

So what's your name?

I'm here, I'm looking at the game and it doesn't seem like Andrew S. is scummy. Though, people are bringing up a good point about IH, but I don't think there is enough proof to lynch him.

You can choose people who others don't feel like wagoning aswell.
I'm so so happy coz today I found the scum. Liking my vote.

[Twito]

I'm here, I'm looking at the game and it doesn't seem like Andrew S. is scummy. Though, people are bringing up a good point about IH, but I don't think there is enough proof to lynch him.

You can choose people who others don't feel like wagoning aswell.
I'm so so happy coz today I found the scum. Liking my vote.

I don't want to wagon, I just don't see much proof on anybody in this game to lynch, I just think that IH, seems to be the most scum like.

Sorry I misjudged you. If you are planning on getting rid of IH go ahead and bus him.

[Twito]

Looking for votes on Fircoal.

[Twito]

I'm going to throw suspicion on lowell here: for basically clearing 3 out of 10 people... that's 33.3%, for reasons that I don't think are valid.

In Switch Mafia I believed I cleared 4/9 people, and was right about 3 of them. I do not recall you throwing suspicion on me there, why now?

Well this is getting interesting.

[Twito]

I would like to point out SV was scum in that game, and I gave no reasoning whatsoever.

And that time she wasn't throwing suspicion and now she is.

[Twito]

I would like to point out SV was scum in that game, and I gave no reasoning whatsoever.

And that time she wasn't throwing suspicion and now she is.

Do you feel that conclusion was intended by the quoted? Thus clearing SV of suspicion.

Kinda yes.

[Twito]

Now that I remember I found Fircoal uberscummy on another game aswell and he turned up town.
And I don't like so much being poked.

Unvote
Vote: SV

[Twito]

= | I'm seriously not seeing too much, though I am having problems to actually get time to do a reread pbpa.

I've been sick alot also, so lately I've mostly only been able to respond to current things in my game.

So what is your illness?

[Twito]

IH caught a virus.

Twito: I find you uberscummy in most games I'm in with you, but you don't see me accusing you or defending you on that basis. Bad bad metagaming.

Oh well I'm sure you are not the only one. And yes it if someone has similar behavior in two different games and I find that behavior very scummy, then that someone dies on other one and turns up town obviously I'm gonna doubt whether I'm wrong in the other game aswell.

[Twito]

I prefer to think of it as a good attempt at avoiding a Townie-Lynch.
Afraid of the fact that i have worked out ur scumbuddies perhaps?

Yes both are obviously true.

Claiming scum are we?

And it does start to look like this is one thread he's avoiding.

Yeah I have the exactly same feeling about him on other threads aswell.

[Twito]

I don't remember reason for my vote so I won't change it until I look it up.

[Twito]

Unvote
Vote: Ripley

[Twito]

This day is way too long.

It's not. If we reach 50 pages it's too long. If we reach 100 it's way too long. Right now it's not long enough.

[Twito]

Haha I never looked the "Joined" dates before!!1 You are all punch of noobs! Holyshit!!111 Feeling very 1337z0rx

[Twito]

I'm extremely wary of the way TCS is jumping through hoops held by Akbar.

FOS: both of them

Scum buddy leading scum buddy.

FOS SV

for framing.

You conveniently left out the part about me threatening to lynch TCS if IH is town.

Why isn't IH lynched yet?

Ok, I'll help ya bandwagon. Of course, if he turns out to be town, this combined with my earlier suspicion of you, will confirm your scum.

Vote IH

That comment just gained a vote.

Unvote
Vote: Akbar

for being obvious scum.

[Twito]

Damn speedlynchers = |

Actially now that we are on it we could finish IH..

[Twito]

You guys are all nuts. No one ever listens to me.

I have a scum. His name is IH. Lynch please.
Another scum, too. Her name is SV.

Then maybe it would be better to shut up and bus your scumbuddy akbar?

[Twito]

Lowell. Have you considered posting a thought out case other than "IH is scum lawl, listen to me, lawl, no one listens to me, lawl."

Then again when talking about IH it's likely that he is scum.

[Twito]

Uuh a deadline in a game I'm not 100% coinfident about lynching scum.. that's just wrong.

[Twito]

Ripley is always appearing so useful. Framing more innocents is a good way to play when you are not even changing your vote along with your case.

[Twito]

Twito away for the weekend.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... start=1500

[Twito]

Twito is back! WHOOHOO!

Should I

FOS: Fircoal

?

Why should you?

Fircoal means that you really shouldn't.

Ok, I'll give you a pass for being ill. Now focus on the second part of what I wrote. What have you contributed to the town?

May I repeat. Have you even read the last few pages?

Are we playing the question game?

Why aren't you, or your scumbuddy, lynched yet?

I have a scumbuddy?

You mistyped "." as "?"?
You do?!

Ok, I'll give you a pass for being ill. Now focus on the second part of what I wrote. What have you contributed to the town?

May I repeat. Have you even read the last few pages?

Are we playing the question game?

Why aren't you, or your scumbuddy, lynched yet?

I have a scumbuddy?

who says you don't?

If he does it isn't me.

:Patiently waits for spectrumvoid to return to vote for IH:

Is SV your buddy?

*BM impatiently awaits the wagon on TCS (who is blatantly scum) to grow.

Why do you want to lynch scum?

[Twito]

Scum we don't have time to catch you please claim scum.

[Twito]

IH, should I hammer you?
I just came to notice that Twito has wit in it. Cool.
Take care and drugs too. Weed..

Mod:

If two players have the same amount of votes, over 4, on deadline what will happen?

[Twito]

6 hours to deadline it seems.

[Twito]

Btw IH it's a good time to claim if you wanna live.. Don't lie that would make the kittens cry.

[Twito]

Note that atm IH is the one getting lynched as we have tie on 5 votes but IH got there first.

[Twito]

Hey buddy!

[Twito]

The people keeping from posting atm are likely to be scum incase IH is town.

[Twito]

From IH voters Akbar has posted on another game.

[Twito]

Actually as Akbar is the counterwagon he would have a reason to want IH lynched as town aswell and best way to do this atm is to shut up.

[Twito]

Lowell is likely scum if IH is town.

[Twito]

Vote: BM

Hmm..

[Twito]

The following morning his body is discovered in his dining room by the rest of the town.

Didn't anyone hear the shot at night? And why the whole town decided to make surprice visit on AndrewS on morning?

[Twito]

Didn't anyone hear the shot at night? And why the whole town decided to make surprice visit on AndrewS on morning?

Some ppl heard the shot at night, but didn't want to leave their homes. The town decided to visit Andrew's house because he was missing obv.

I still don't get it. Who did you say shot Andrew?

:D

continued FOS: Twito. I still say you're attacking BM for opportunistic reasons rather than real ones. I read back and remembered why I had exonerated him in the first place. That reasoning still stands.

When have I been attacking BM?

[Twito]

i think he refers to the fact that as soon as i accused u, you voted for me-giving no reasons other than OMGUS.
BM

He can answer guestions directed to him himself I believe and point me to correct posts so that I can prove him wrong.

I could see BM as scum.
I could see TCS as scum.
I could see Fircoal as scum.
I could see Akbar as scum.
I could actually see many of you as scum.

Actually

unvote

Vote: Akbar

I want a claim out of him. I have my reasons.

[Twito]

No. I have my reasons. However, unlike your mysterious fishing attempt,(BM’s support noted) I will actually share mine. I don’t take orders from suspected scum.

I take that as you will claim when I'm confirmed town. Or when nobody suspects me other than you.

"I feel TCS, Ripley, and Lowell are all townies."
It is well known that town does not benefit from roleclaiming. The only way your getting a claim out of me is if these 3 individuals think it’s a good idea.

You have your facts all mixed up. Town actually benefits a lot from roleclaiming. What the hell is wrong with you? Are you scum?
It's too fking obvious you have listed 2 town and 1 your scumbuddy meaning there is no change all of them will say it's a good idea.

And look! in jumps Twito, post 334, with a post so terrible it could almost have been written by Fircoal himself.

It's actually very good post if you read it all. The whole sentence. I think you are just OMGUSsing here.

Oh shit I just noticed we have the PM's in the first post.. Bitchy.

Until you can explain your Akbar vote over all of the other candidates, my vote remains on you. I think right now Akbar is the least likely scum candidate among us.

I think IH and Akbar were both scum and now there is Akbar. Knowing his allignment would help otherwise I can't analyze the information available.

I wouldn't mind a Twito lynch actually.

Me neither. I don't think he is too useful atm he doesn't seem to have any clear suspects or anything. He wasn't even in yesterdays IH lynch but was highly againts it when IH was so obviously scum and the wagon was so well based. Yeap Twito must be scum.

[Twito]

Would convenient conclusion be that SL didn't have a reason and that TCS is a fucking dumbass?

[Twito]

All of them have ended since that?

[Twito]

3. Twito, why do you want a claim out of Akbar??

Cuz I think he is scum and that there were wagons on two scum yesterday. And cuz of post 376.

[Twito]

Sorry internet broke on Sunday and I've had a lot of stuff irl aswell. I'll be active and catch up when it's fixed.

[Twito]

Akbar scum appears to be alive.

[Twito]

Has he roleclaimed?

[Twito]

Bah.

[Twito]

Owned.