Time to try an analysis:
Post 10,
Post 14,
Post 16:
Start of the whole Nai-Coron debate.
Post 19,
Post 20,
Post 21:
Perfect votes Coron for no reason. HackerHuck calls him out on it and Coron states that perfect is scum.
Post 27,
Post 30:
Apparently, Nai and Jules feel that the slip-up hints at scum.
Post 36:
Perfect attempts to ease his vote off Coron.
Post 42:
Hucky asks Jules if the "slip-up" is worth Lynch-2.
Post 43:
luna jumps on the Coron-wagon, for "seeming to act a bit scummy and too sure of himself".
Post 44:
Claim! D: D:
Post 46:
Further attempts from Hucky to counter the Coron-wagon.
Post 51:
luna explains her vote.
Post 52:
Nai's reasoning for voting Coron. Since when was arrogance a scumtell?
Post 72:
Hucky's thoughts on the game so far.
Blech, *abandons linking to posts*
Stewie's the first to go after Jules. In retrospect, this looks a bit weak. Then we get another exchange between Coron and Nai, Post 115-118. Again, Hucky seems very reasonable in Post 119. In Post 121, Nai FoSes Hucky for this, which I find odd. The exchange between Nai and Hucky afterwards only has me lean more and more to Hucky as town. Post 162 once again doesn't look very good from Nai. Here's Post 171:
Nai wrote:My biggest reason? Being completely overconfident in himself with absolutely no reason to be so, probably, followed by defending Jules with a made up story.
Overconfidence is not a scumtell, and the second part was after Nai voted Coron to begin with.
Post 174 looks hypocritical, as Nai's been doing the same thing himself. Post 185 from Nightfall is very overdefensive. Stewie's inclined to change his vote to Coron in Post 190. Jules notes the hypocrisy of Post 174 in Post 195. It gets interesting around Post 205, because that's where Kelly replaces in. She just hops in and FoSes me. Post 210, Kelly's on Nai's side in the argument, but thinks that neither should be lynched, as they're the most active players. Post 212, Kelly says Nai should be able to make a stronger argument.
Coron wrote:[sarcasm]Alright! Why don't we play mafia this way? LET'S ALL BE FRIENDS AND NOT ACCUSE ANYONE OF BEING SCUM AND SIT HERE AND STAGNATE FOR 3 MONTHS! Once all that is done the mod will put a 5 day deadline down and productivity will be up 600% for that but we'll still only get about 30 posts in that time and end up lynching someone mostly randomly. I love that style of play man. I wish we had more of that around here.[/sarcasm]
I wanted to restate this point because of the sheer irony.
Post 236-239 are interesting. First, ShadowLurker votes me, Coron then FoSes SL. 238, Kelly votes Hucky for being the scummiest Coron cheerleader. Coron then points out that you should vote the scummiest player, not limit yourself to a group. Post 246, Kelly states that Hucky, Jules and I are the Coron cheerleader squad. In 273, Kelly switches to voting Jules. I find Post 275 a bit odd. CTD puts Jules as newbie scum. Personally, I feel that if there is newbie scum in this game, it was perfect. Nai puts forth a scumgroup in Post 281, consisting of Coron, Jules, and Hucky, the last two mainly for interaction with Coron (and he felt Hucky was town). Then we get the Juleswagon, which ends in the Ear-claim. In Post 379, Nightfall proposes a partial mass claim of sorts. Post 414, SL says Stewie's scum. Post 415, Hucky agrees on Stewie. 419, SL votes Hucky. We then get a reread by GreenLiquid, which I still really like. Lots of debates spark up after that between GreenLiquid and others. MaMa replaces Stewie. Post 563 looks real good to me. Post 568 is MaMa's first real post. While he doesn't offer very much in the realm of arguments, it's worth taking a look at. Then we get an analysis from CTD in Post 572. Post 612, Kelly votes Hucky. Nai and Hucky claims, we have some discussion on those.
Blech, the quality gets lower the farther I get in the game, but meh.
Anyway, time to opinionate:
CrashTextDummie (Replacing conflux): conflux didn't do a whole lot. CTD, well, he made that big analysis post. He put Hucky and me as scum, SL as Town and Kelly as, I believe, probable town. I do not find myself agreeing with his opinions at all.
Coron: Has, in general, been playing Coronish. I don't suspect him for this. I think he's town.
GreenLiquid: Town. Made a really good analysis, and I find myself agreeing with that.
HackerHuck: Town. Deserves a Scummy if he isn't.
Jules: I'm undecided. I'd like to see what Apeiron does before deciding.
ShadowLurker (Replacing lunalovegood): luna made a pretty large scumtell in the beginning, and SL hasn't really been doing a lot to alleviate my suspicions.
Nai: Scummy. Claim's in the middle, and I do not like at all the way he's been attacking Coron throughout the way. His lynch is by far preferable over a Hucky lynch.
Nightfall: Lurker, as usual. I don't like the way he reacted to me calling him out for lurking (by saying I think he's scum in every game). That's a scumtell, though not a big one.
Kelly Chen (Replacing perfect62834): Perfect's early vote on Coron is a huge newb scumtell. Again, Kelly's not really giving off any townie vibes at all. I'm still convinced she's scum.
Machiavellian-Mafia (Replacing Stewie): Posted a very meh-ish analysis. That's the only thing we've seen from MaMa so far. Stewie gave off some scumvibes, but nothing really bad.
If I had to decide on a scumteam right now, it'd be CTD/SL/Kelly.
All I meant was that scum might choose not to use their night actions as a tactic, but they would not want to have the chance that their night actions won't work.
