Apeiron, and MM are the only living players who have yet to answer my "starting item" question, but I figure it will be best to go on before people get annoyed and strt dropping out like flies....
Okay, so here goes....
As I'm sure almost all of you remember, Nai and Coron had a huge arguement earlier in this game. This arguement all began because of one post. My very first post.
Nightfall wrote:Random FOS : Nai
Random Vote : Coron
Coron thought I was FOS'ing Nai (my so called scum buddy) to distance myself from him for later in the game. This however was not the case.
I started this game with an artifact. My artifact was an ancient deck of cards.
I was told that I did not have any control over them though, and that they would do what they'd like.
So, pre game night 1 these cards decided to shuffle, and reveal a card to me.
I was told that the card shown was an old expression for the term "no".
Not knowing what exactly I was being told, I looked at the players list.
That was when I say nai. nai = no? Not sure as to what it ment I decided to FOS
Nai in order to leave a little breadcrum for later. This is also the reason that I asked Nai a few times if he had any type of post restiction, or any type of forced action. He voted Coron pretty quickly after he attacked me so I thought that my item might have made him have to vote those who voted me? Anyways, the game went on and Jules claimed the "ear of the diviner". I didnt make much of it at the time but I believed his claim. By this point I had become of the mindset that my item had something to do with Nai, but I suddenly recalled something from my pm. Was there more to my item? I checked my PM and I had infact over looked something. The deck of cards was being held together by something. That something was "The Hands of the Diviner".
So this leads me to believe a few things,
1) I would think the ear would most likely start with a town member, which would make Jules'/jules' role likely protown.
2) If Jules is town then MM/Stewie is not mafia, and therefore also town.
3) Shadow claims to have an item with part of the title being "of the diviner", yet no one has yet to claim having a record of this item.
4) I believe Shadow as scum would create the idea that this item existed for three reasons. A> To make it appear that he has a way of finding scum while only revealing MM's alignment (someone who quite possibly is already cleared by the use of another item) B> Drawing possible doc protection away from people who really need it. C> Claiming to have used a diferent item, gives him an excuse for not using the ear.
5) If we were to believe that Shadow's claimed artifact is real, that would mean that we would likely have a total of 3 items "of the diviner". 2 of these items are directly linked to each other. And together these two act like a super cop item. To have a 3rd "of the diviner" item, and another cop one at that, seems a little repetitive and out of place.
6) Shadow claimed to have investigated MM last night because he "forgot" that Jules asked the ears about him night one. I find this rather unlikely, Possible but unlikely. Not meaning to suckup but, I dont think it would be something that Shadow would overlook.
7)If Shadow did investigate MM like he stated last night, why would he so soon after list MM as his 2nd top suspect? It makes no sense. I really cant see Shadow "forgeting" his own investigation result, and doing so so soon after he made it.
8) After being confronted with the info in point 7 above, Shadow responds with:
ShadowLurker wrote:
Oh and I obviously think MM is pretty much protown although he would've been my 2nd scummiest canindate today ignoring the investigation.
Pretty much protown? What kind of investigation result did you get? MM = Somewhat innocent? And if you did get an innocent result on him, why would we care to hear that he would have been the "2nd scummiest canindate of the day" if we were to ignore your investigation? So you found out he was town, but you still want to point fingers at him?
Vote: Shadow
I need some answers... I think we all deserve em.
(P.S. I was one of the people that was voiceing his opinion that Nai should have used his item last night. This was because, scum knew where the ear was since after Jules claimed Shadow confirmed he recieved it; also I thought it would at least give us one more night for one more question for the ears.)
Once Nightfall comes, everyone's dead...
