Apeiron wrote:So exactly what have we learned by having everyone tell whether or not their artifact was "X of the Diviner"?
Nightfall tried to connect the dots and link someone to being scum, but the evidence isn't very solid. Now Apeiron can you tell us who your suspects are at this point?
As far as I'm concerned, a majority of that 35 pages is, more or less, useless filler to this game. At least for the time being, since it concerns people who are, to me, leaning towards town and/or are still alive. I'd only call about 10 of it usefull for this game at this point.
Nightfall didn't actually say anything about the "X of the diviner" yet, did he? I don't recall reading any fabulous revelation.
Nai wrote:As far as I'm concerned, a majority of that 35 pages is, more or less, useless filler to this game. At least for the time being, since it concerns people who are, to me, leaning towards town and/or are still alive. I'd only call about 10 of it usefull for this game at this point.
Sounds useful to me. Who are these people you think are town? Also it doesn't have to be posts ABOUT people, posts from people would work too. I'm pretty sure everyone in this game has at least a few posts.
Oh and the reason I haven't posted much is because I've already outlined who I think is scum and have my vote placed there.
might I point out that there are 8ish people in this game who have not in fact placed a vote? They need to get off their lazy butts and help us find scum.
Right now, I'm really working off gut feelings, since I haven't found any real data that pushes people one way or another. This is my best list.
Town:
Nai
Nightfall
Town-ish:
Kelly Chen
Machiavellian-Mafia
Neutral:
Coron
Scummy:
Shadowlurker
Zindaras
Apeiron
No read:
Bogre
Green Liquid
Really, these are no more than gut feelings here. As for Bogre and Green Liquid, they've been lurking so much and such that I can't really get any read on them whatsoever.
Unfortunately, I also have nothing to really build a case from, nor a real good reason to vote any of the 'scummy' people, other than gut feelings. And I don't want to put a vote on someone just because of that.
If it's the best you got it's the best you got. Do you have a problem with random votes at the begining of day 1? I know I don't because they are the best possible votes for that point in time, if you feel your gut is the only way you can distinguish right now, I say go for it(even if I don't totally agree with your assessment of who is scummy).
I don't random vote day 1 most of the time, unless I feel really odd. "Random vote" should be just that, a random vote. A vote for someone for no reason, based off dice roll or you just liking their name. Random vote off a gut feeling isn't random. And there's no way you can have a gut feeling during a random voting stage.
I don't feel comfortable voting off a gut feeling, because I can't put anything behind it. And we really should have reasons behind our votes on day 2. But we have such a lack of information right now, even with all the posts we have.
You know, you guys are right, I haven't given enough to this game lately. Expect me to reread by Saturday, with new incites and hopefully something to get the rest of you talking.
I'm still here. This has to be the most frustrating game I've ever played. I'll look over some things but I'm still suspicious of Coron & Nai, and possibly Jules.
