Hey, let me just post this now just to post something at all... I'll try to finish up the pbpa's sometime this century.
The aforementioned "long version"
A papaya
1. RV: Mcstab
2. Jokes with xdaamno
3. Jokes with Nekka-Lucifer
12. Votes Nekka-Lucifer for "sucking [sic] at mafia"
14. Unvotes Nekka after being PMed by him
16. No idea who to vote for
21. Comes out against no-lynch
25. Votes McStab for lurking on purpose
Overall: A papaya doesn't give out a whole lot of information. He doesn't often comment upon the scumminess of other players. In most situations, I would find this pretty scummy, but his choices haven't been terribly damning. Not necessarily an auto-lynch, but someone to keep in mind for later days if he neglects to contribute further.
Fletcher
1. Votes Nekka-Lucifer for uncertain reasons
3. Unvotes Nekka-Lucifer for uncertain reasons
5. Votes Xdaamno for vote hopping
11. Indicates that he would be ok with a no-lynch, but prefers to lynch
12. A little wishy washy here. Gives a good argument that no-lynch would benefit the town if Nekka-Lucifer comes up scum, says that he thinks there's a 'good chance' of Nekka being scum, and then declines to vote no-lynch. This play looks like he's trying very hard not to stick his neck out.
14. Asks mlaker about his thoughts on the game.
Overall: Not the lynch for today. He posts a decent amount of content, and thus is not a great candidate for us to get rid of just yet. His waffling defense of no-lynch and suspicion of Nekka's scumminess puts up a red flag in my mind, but it's not enough to lynch today. If Nekka-Lucifer does happen to come up scum, I would definitely encourage the town to give Fletch another look.
Haschel Cedricson
2. Casts suspicion on Nekka for being scummy and/or new. Has a gut feeling about xdaamno hiding in plain sight.
3. Votes mlaker for basically joke reasons
6. Misstates the odds on lynching scum tonight. Might be bad math, and if Nekka is scum, could be a definite scumtell. Pretty inconsequential at the moment. Comes out against no-lynch. FOS's Yogurt for suggesting no-lynch and xyzzy for advocating not lynching every night. Votes Fletcher for trying to lead the town to believe that Nekka was scum. States that he believes Nekka was town.
10. FOS's McStab, not sure why yet.
Overall: Haschel's play is pretty unclear to me at the moment. I'd need to see more of him before I can make a call. I don't like his vote on mlaker and I definitely don't like his Fletch vote. It seems pretty contrived. He votes Fletch for making the assumption that Nekka was scum, which then makes one wonder if Haschel knows whether or not Nekka was town. Definitely a figure to look at.
Haut Boy/inHim
1. Votes xyzzy, random?
2. Votes Nekka for making a pretty dumb statement.
3. Calls Nekka on bad argument
---Becomes inHim---
1. Posts something so useful to me that I'll repost:
inHim wrote:
Nekka-Lucifer (5): (MidnightSun, Fletcher, IH, A Papaya, Haut Boy)
Also votes Haschel after first reading.
2. Quickly switched vote to xdaamno, following me.
4. Identifies xdaanmo, xyzzy, and mlaker as his top suspects.
Overall: I'm pretty sure this guy is town. I don't like the play of inHim as much as I did Haut Boy's.
IH
1. Votes Fletcher.
4. Votes Nekka for trying to make an intentional claim seem innocuous.
5. Votes Yogurt, not sure why
8. Votes papaya for pretty legit reasons
Overall: Not a whole lot yet. He has pretty decent reasons for voting papaya (and Nekka, though in hindsight I contradict myself). I need him to post more.
McStab
1. RV: Yogurt
2. Expresses amusement at Haschel's badlogic
3. Comes out against no-lynch.
4. I don't really like this post at all. A
FOS:McStab
for trying to say alot while saying nothing, and justifying his lurking.
5. Says he thinks Haschel is innocent, Yogurt is scummy, and that xdaamno can't be scummy because he's in the spotlight too much. I really, really don't like this reasoning.
Overall: I don't like McStab's play all that much. Saying a lot but not really saying anything is pretty scummy behavior. His reasoning clearing xdaamno was incredibly specious, leading me to think that if xdaamno comes up scum at some point, McStab might be on his team.
mlaker
1. Votes TCS, pure OMGUS.
3. Unvotes on 'a hunch'.
5. Comments on xdaamno as his top choice for scum, but neglects to vote him.
Overall: I'd like to see more content from mlaker. I'm a little suspicious of the fact that mlaker instantly voted me for an admittedly weak reason and he's not willing to do the same for xdaamno here.
FOS: mlaker
Nekka-Lucifer
- For completeness
1. Votes a papaya
3. Unnecessarily claims townie
8. Makes a "maybe when I'm mafia" statement, that makes me uncomfortable.
14 & 15. Points to A papaya as possible scum. This could go either way for me.
OVerall: I'm pretty sure Nekka was just bad town, but there is certainly a chance that he is scum. Therefore, in my estimation, we should ignore the possibilities of his alignment and focus on who is the best lynch
today
. We can vote based on his alignment when we actually know it.
The rest as I have time/motivation.