ryan wrote:Zeek: Let me ask you this, would Estes be a better lynch than Sorin?
I guess I would say Sorin because there is a slim chance that Estes is a cop, so if we're wrong it's better to just lose a townie than a cop. But I'd say I'm fairly sure Estes is not a cop so it doesn't matter that much.
Estes wrote:
ZeekLTK wrote:It's pretty clear I'm a miller and pro-town
Clear because you say so? Oh ok.
No, not because I "say so".... we already went over this.
By saying I'm going to give a guilty that means I'm either a miller or mafia. I wouldn't do this if I was a town who got innocent because there is no benefit to that, so I have to be miller or mafia. Me revealing as miller helps the town in several ways such as j-man can confirm his insanity, Gatorguy, a likely townie, is not lynched, etc. Even if Gatorguy is not town, me revealing will help us figure that out.
There is nothing anti-town about my reveal (if there is I'd like to hear it) so I don't see how anyone can suspect me as possibly being mafia any more. If anything, it just looks more suspicious on the parts of those who do try to make a case against me.
Also your role doesn't make sense. In the episode, looking at it as though Dawg Cartman is a cop, he gets guilty on innocent people (Butters) AND on guilty people (the teacher)*. So if anything, you would be a paranoid cop. However, you claim you got an innocent result. Dawg never got an innocent result in the episode, so that doesn't add up.
*This is opposed to j-man's where that Cartman gets guilty results on innocent people and does not get guilty when he actually comes up against the real guilty person, which is why I am inclined to believe he is an insane cop.