There is a mistake in your reasoning here. If FLOC is Mafia, he lied about being a doc all the time, and as such could not "target" anyone. This doesn't mean Nano would have been a safe NK for the mafia. On the contrary, if FLOC is mafia, there would have been a big risk that the real doc (if there is one, but the mafia wouldn't know) protected Nano. So FLOC = mafia, Nano = cop is quite possible.Bookitty wrote:Faeren Lord of Carlisle is Mafia, and lying about protecting Nanosauromo. Since he is Mafia, it would be a simple matter just to target someone else. This doesn't work logically for me, though, because why would Mafia leave the cop alive to finger one of them? So I don't think this scenario works, unless Nanosauromo is also Mafia.
First, you are not really ready to assume no false claims (not ready to believe the claims), but then suddenly you are pretty sure both me and Yagami are scum. That's a pretty big jump in two paragraphs...Bookitty wrote:Assuming no false claims -- I'm not really ready to assume that yet though.
/../
FOS: YagamiLight and Samruc, with a vote for one of the two likely to follow. (Barring further evidence I'm pretty sure they are both scum.)
Nano is right, if there were another cop in this game it would be really bad play not to counterclaim. The other options are that there is no cop at all, or Nano is telling the truth.Nanosauromo wrote:And what would the "real cop" gain from waiting to bust me? If the "real cop" even exists, me being alive makes it less likely that he will get doc protection. Furthermore, he'd be letting a known (to him) scum live. If there were a "real cop," he would have busted me long before now. I am the real cop.
On a sidenote, (some setup-WIFOM, but I can't resist), there are already a big number of powerroles confirmed/semiconfirmed. If the setup consists of 2 Masons, one town roleblocker (FL) and a one-shot-vig, that's already a quite powerful town. A cop+doc pair combined with this seems improbable/ridiculously hard to balance. (Not sure what roles mafia could have; a godfather feels pretty standard, but that role requires a cop to be useful, which would imply Nano is telling the truth. This is pure guessing though.)
As a summary, I find FLOC's claim improbable and his play is still scummy. I think it's time we take care of him soon.