Food Fight Mafia - WHO OWNS THE SCHOOL???

[Tarhalindur]

Okay, something is rotten in the house of Denmark, and its name probably is Skruffs or Battle Mage (maybe both). Given the flavor behind the second kill and something I spotted shortly before yesterdays lynch (but didn't have time to comment on) that makes me less certain that Battle Mage is guilty, Skruffs is currently higher on my scumdar.

I wonder if Betty Boop has anything to say about it.

In other news, I feel the sudden urge to test something:

Lob celery stick at DrippingGoofball

[Gorrad]

Given the flavor behind the second kill and something I spotted shortly before yesterdays lynch (but didn't have time to comment on) that makes me less certain that Battle Mage is guilty, Skruffs is currently higher on my scumdar.

Care to elaborate?

[Skruffs]

Okay.
"1. The administration is out to get us, and is probably enlisting help from brownnosing students. "

Gorrad, where did you form this hypothesis - with the brownnosing students corollary?



The JDodge 'murder' makes me look very bad. I realize this. I was very suspicious of JDodge yesterday, and I said so. He was pretty oppurtunistic in when and at who he decided to toss his food around. I will note, and this is of course, WIFOM, that JDodge would not be considered nearly as much a threat to ME as BM would be, and if I had a killing ability, BM would be dead today, wether it was SK, mafia, or vig.


I would like everyone who thinks that I am likely mafia because I am the lunchlady to look at the silent speaker's role name and ability. He was the School Secretary (Which would be considered Admin) and protecter of players. So yes, WHILE it's possible (LIKELY) there is a school employee mafia of some sort, there are ALSO school employees who are NOT MAFIA (Proven!)

I Would really like (BEFORE the food starts being thrown) to look at Battle Mage's successions of claims about his role, abilities, name, 'power role', etc, and what he was accusing/fishing at the same time about yesterday. Did it look like he really knew what the bad behavior notes was, as it pertained to the game?



Tarhalindur -
"No, I'm, like, saying that there are people in this cafeteria who, like, want to take over this school, and they're, like, responsible for this food fight somehow.

We must, like, totally get them sent home before we, like, lose control of the school! Who's with me?

One! Two! Three! Four!
Let's go find some scum to smore! "
You said this yesterday, adn I called you on it, and you said you were just guessing, I believe. Can you share any more information with us about this?

[Erg0]

The way I see it, the first kill was made by the administration-mafia. Administration is used in the literal sense here. There's usually a group of high-ups in the school called the administration- this includes principal, vice-principals, department heads, and other people who don't teach but handle administrative affairs. This would sometimes include the librarian, but never the lunch lady. In this scenario, they are getting rid of students- probably budget cuts or something (http://www.scarygoround.com/index.php?date=20051011).

Sorry if I missed this, but how does the School Secretary being town fit in with this theory?

Also, that flavour definitely seems to point at Skruffs, perhaps as an SK. I'm going to try and re-read his stuff from day 1 and hope that my head hurts less this time.

[Sir Tornado]

Erg0, look at the flavor. The secretary looks like some sort of renegede admin. Plus the fact that the secretary was

dismissed

, which I don't think could have been the work of any student.

Not saying all admin are mafia or all students are not (in fact after thinking more clearly, I think second kill would have been made by a student)

Day one is over, and I guess most of the food is out in the open. Can we have a mass claim of all our foodstuff (only name, not quantity) to avoid reread of entire thread to see who had what?

Sayonara.

[Gorrad]

Okay.
"1. The administration is out to get us, and is probably enlisting help from brownnosing students. "

Gorrad, where did you form this hypothesis - with the brownnosing students corollary?

If it was purely adults, we could lynch every adult and win, despite some being pro-town. There has to be a mix, otherwise it would be too easy. Do you really think there would be a game- a DGB game at that- where rolenames would be dead givaways?

Also, erg0, Sir T has it right. The secretary was a renegade.

[Sir Tornado]

If it was purely adults, we could lynch every adult and win, despite some being pro-town. There has to be a mix, otherwise it would be too easy. Do you really think there would be a game- a DGB game at that- where rolenames would be dead givaways?

I agree with this. This is the reason why I think there is a second scum group made of students. (so, lunch lady is unlikely to be the person to kill JDodge)

[PlaysWithSquirrels]

I'd really like to see a case against somebody in this game that wasn't based on flavor. When I get a chance, I'll do a good reread and let you guys know where I stand. As it is right now, I'm behind in a lot of things. Irl and mafia.

[Skruffs]

Also,

The lunchlady serves food to the students. I do not believe she personally prepares it (though it's possible?), I think it's a lot more likely there is a cook of some sort.

I also agree with the 'not just adults' scumgroup theory, just like I agree that the foreign language players (wether students or teachers) are not all scum or town.

[Lowell]

Okay.
"1. The administration is out to get us, and is probably enlisting help from brownnosing students. "

Gorrad, where did you form this hypothesis - with the brownnosing students corollary?

If it was purely adults, we could lynch every adult and win, despite some being pro-town. There has to be a mix, otherwise it would be too easy. Do you really think there would be a game- a DGB game at that- where rolenames would be dead givaways?

I also very much agree with this. I don't think we'll get much information from role names.

I'm still of the opinion that BM and Skruffs are both innocent. WIFOM if you must, but I can't bring myself to believe either would claim a role if they thought there was even a chance their role would give them away.

[Sir Tornado]

The thing is, that they claimed before we got the idea of admins being scum.

For the lack of time to look up a japanese word: Sayonara

[Skruffs]

Yes, but if I was an sk who killed by cooking, and I claimed to be someone who worked in an area where food is cooked, and almost got lynched, I wouldn't kill the first nihght, esp after claiming. I don't think anyone is that shortsighted.

[Sir Tornado]

Skruffs-sans, If you are a sk, you usually have no choice but to kill.

[Battle Mage]

Yes, but if I was an sk who killed by cooking, and I claimed to be someone who worked in an area where food is cooked, and almost got lynched, I wouldn't kill the first nihght, esp after claiming. I don't think anyone is that shortsighted.

unless of course, like most SK's/mafia groups, you didnt know your kill method at the start of the game...

@Sir T-ive seen a game or 2 where groups are forced to kill if they can, with a random kill being made if they dont submit, but usually, not NKing is an option.

BM

[Skruffs]

I wouldn't know, I've never been an sk.


I'm going to focus on people who didn't toss food on one of the three main wagons late day 1, for starters. I don't like "either/or" mentality regarding bm/skruffs as scum (false dilemma), and probably people who said one thing but acted another.

[Skruffs]

Bm :
Open your eyes.

[Battle Mage]

I wouldn't know, I've never been an sk.


I'm going to focus on people who didn't toss food on one of the three main wagons late day 1, for starters. I don't like "either/or" mentality regarding bm/skruffs as scum (false dilemma), and probably people who said one thing but acted another.

And you've never played in a game with an SK?

What do you mean by 'open your eyes'?

[Tarhalindur]

Erg0, look at the flavor. The secretary looks like some sort of renegede admin. Plus the fact that the secretary was

dismissed

, which I don't think could have been the work of any student.

Not saying all admin are mafia or all students are not (in fact after thinking more clearly, I think second kill would have been made by a student)

Day one is over, and I guess most of the food is out in the open. Can we have a mass claim of all our foodstuff (only name, not quantity) to avoid reread of entire thread to see who had what?

Sayonara.

I have reason to believe that a mass food claim would be a very bad idea for us. I will NOT elaborate at this time.

Tarhalindur -
"No, I'm, like, saying that there are people in this cafeteria who, like, want to take over this school, and they're, like, responsible for this food fight somehow.

We must, like, totally get them sent home before we, like, lose control of the school! Who's with me?

One! Two! Three! Four!
Let's go find some scum to smore! "
You said this yesterday, adn I called you on it, and you said you were just guessing, I believe. Can you share any more information with us about this?

It should be rather obvious by now that I have role-based information. Quit fishing.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I will be withholding my food at this time.

[Tarhalindur]

Given the flavor behind the second kill and something I spotted shortly before yesterdays lynch (but didn't have time to comment on) that makes me less certain that Battle Mage is guilty, Skruffs is currently higher on my scumdar.

Care to elaborate?

No.

[Gorrad]

Tar, I find your withholding information infuriating. I'm trusting you, even though you did not trust me earlier, but I find your uncooperativeness scummy. Scum have more to hide than town.

[Tarhalindur]

Tar, I find your withholding information infuriating. I'm trusting you, even though you did not trust me earlier, but I find your uncooperativeness scummy. Scum have more to hide than town.

It should be rather obvious by now that I have role-based information. Quit fishing.

Not originally directed at you, but still relevant here. If you want me to role claim, stop beating around the bush and say so, because revealing my information necessarily entails a role claim.

[Battle Mage]

Tar, I find your withholding information infuriating. I'm trusting you, even though you did not trust me earlier, but I find your uncooperativeness scummy. Scum have more to hide than town.

FoS: Gorrad

So scummy...

Tarhalindur, if you have a power role, and dont want to claim, FFS SHUT UP ABOUT IT.

[Gorrad]

The only information I REALLY want is your food, because what you threw earlier poses a direct threat to my health. Otherwise, it's up to you to claim or not, but if your claiming gives us more insight, I don't know why you wouldn't. That's why I'm trusting you, because I don't know your role, and you do.

[Tarhalindur]

The only information I REALLY want is your food, because what you threw earlier poses a direct threat to my health. Otherwise, it's up to you to claim or not, but if your claiming gives us more insight, I don't know why you wouldn't. That's why I'm trusting you, because I don't know your role, and you do.

The next time you ask me to claim my food, I will alpha strike you. (Hell, I'm tempted to alpha strike you NOW for your continued inquiries.) Unless I am very much mistaken, there is NO GOOD REASON for town to ask what someone has in their lunchbox. QUIT FISHING.