Screw the players - Bad Idea - Game Over

[Guardian]

we can lynch like normal, rite?

vote: skitzler

[hasdgfas]

no, you shoot someone to end the day.

[bird1111]

Middle finger of annoyance: Everyone who shot yesterday

Someone wasted not one but TWO of our limited bullets. Good job.

Addition: We also got little real discussion because of that, therefor that show was even less helpful than if we had discussed. So whoever's shot was counted just seriously hurt the town.

Discussion is a good thing. Talk now, shoot later. That probably would have kept Jordan alive.

:extremlygoodposting:

I don't understand why everyone is so trigger happy. You only get one bullet.

:goodposting:

Anyone who is a /in townie and wants to win should NOT be shooting anytime soon.

[Iammars]

It's a shame that this is more like one shot Texas Justice rather than the actual Bad Idea Mafia. I thought that this was going to be like actual Bad Idea.

[Thestatusquo]

shoot XYZZY

[PokerFace]

Ok I need to read the thread better. With all the shooting I didn't realize there was that much discussion day 1.

Deductions:

I doubt TSQ is /in and town with that being his second shot post.

And Rishi is obv out cause he admitted it and asked the question do we have numbers in our pm's. If he was /in he's already no the answer to that.

Also we should follow a format simular to that which was in the original bad idea

Vote:
Shooter: X
Target: Y

[Thestatusquo]

Shoot pokerface

[Iceforge]

sorry to everybody for being such a quickpuller on this day!

Regret I did my shoot now; I agree there should have been more discussion. For a moment this morning I was just 100% sure he was scum, so I acted to quickly.

[Iammars]

So, you admit to losing your shot?

[Alan Redgown]

sorry to everybody for being such a quickpuller on this day!

Regret I did my shoot now; I agree there should have been more discussion. For a moment this morning I was just 100% sure he was scum, so I acted to quickly.

You really shouldn't go on gut instincts like that. It's nice that we can kill people based on hunches in this game, except you probably wasted another bullet.

EDIT: Table of people who have posted in this thread, minus Kaleidoscope's two usernames:
[mrow]Player[col]# of Posts[col]Posting Order[col]Status Alan Redgown[col]5 bird1111[col]7 Bookitty[col]5 brokenscraps[col]2 Cephrir[col]3 CornerMan[col]4 destructor[col]4 Draux[col]5 Elias_the_thief[col]2 Elmo[col]4 Guardian[col]4 hasdgfas[col]7 Hjallti[col]12 Iammars[col]5 Iceforge[col]7 JDodge[col]1 JordanA24[col]12 Kinetic[col]2 klebian[col]3 mnowax[col]1 oEJo[col]9 OhGodMyLife[col]1 PokerFace[col]9 Rishi[col]9 skitzer[col]12 Thestatusquo[col]4 Thyroidectomy[col]1 Vaughn[col]1 xyzzy[col]3 YagamiLight[col]6 YvonneSeer[col]1

I think it's fairly safe to assume that contained within this table are the 12 /innies. (The table is a work-in-progress.)

[bird1111]

sorry to everybody for being such a quickpuller on this day!

Regret I did my shoot now; I agree there should have been more discussion. For a moment this morning I was just 100% sure he was scum, so I acted to quickly.

You really shouldn't go on gut instincts like that. It's nice that we can kill people based on hunches in this game, except you probably wasted another bullet.

How is it nice that we can kill based on hunches? If you are going to use your kill; you had better have several good reasons for it.

[Cephrir]

Shooter: Klebian
Target: Skitzer

klebian still has a bullet if he's /in, because I still have mine. YvonneSeer probably shot Jordan, and Skitzer needs to die in case Iceforge is /out or scum.

Also, TSQ is obviously not /in and town.

[Thestatusquo]

shoot: Cephrir

[Rishi]

<list deleted>

I think it's fairly safe to assume that contained within this list are the 12 /innies.

That was helpful.

[JordanA24]

May I say Bah! to the game...

and to those who shot me.

[YagamiLight]

shoot: Cephrir

You do realize that you would have already used your shot on pokerface right?

[Iammars]

So, would asking the person who lost their shot yesterday to claim a good idea?

[PokerFace]

shoot: Cephrir

You do realize that you would have already used your shot on pokerface right?

he actually hit xyzzy before me. See post 154. He is either Scum or /out. If he is /out he will get bored eventually but if he keeps doing it for a long time we may need to shoot him cause he is scum

[Cephrir]

Saying that will just make him do it more, you know.

[skitzer]

I'm glad you shot me. This game was definitely a bad idea.

P.S. I'm town, anyway. 10 players, 2 mafia, have fun.

[PokerFace]

I'm glad you shot me. This game was definitely a bad idea.

P.S. I'm town, anyway. 10 players, 2 mafia, have fun.

I just got an idea. And idea that saves bullets and let's us see if skitzer is mafia.

If forge is not /in and town (Meaning skitzer does not die when forensics checks in)

Vote:
Shooter: Skitzer
Target: anyone we can confirm as an out

The shot works he is town. And this way we don't loose 2 bullets.
Shot fails or he refuses to fire than he is mafia

Asuming that fails

Vote:
Shooter: Kinetic
Target: Skitzer

we have him test his wifom or we go with cephir's plan

[skitzer]

OK. But I'm probably dead anyway.

Let's see what happens.

[PokerFace]

either those 2 options or

Shooter: Skitzer
Target: Kinetic

But I am not so sure it is wise to promote the drinking of his wine for if Kinetic is /out and dies it will encourage other /outs or scum to do the same thing.

[Alan Redgown]

Here is a brief summary of my opinions on each player:

Alan Redgown- (I know my status.)
bird1111- Has been active since the beginning of the game. /innie.
Bookitty- Not overly active, seems to be acting. /outie.
brokenscraps- Very inactive, has only commented a few times. /outie.
Cephrir- Seems to care about the game. /innie.
CornerMan- Likely target of the mafia last night. /outie.
destructor- Just...seems like an /innie.
Draux- Not very active, seems like an /outie.
Elias_the_thief- Only 2 posts? Seems extremely /outie.
Elmo- Short posts, seems like a mere spectator. /outie.
Guardian- Doesn't seem to have read the rules. /outie.
hasdgfas- Also just seems like an /innie.
Hjallti- Has actually analyzed the game some. /innie.
Iammars- Seems to be /innie.
Iceforge- /innie.
JDodge- Can't judge. Probably /innie, but may have been pulling our leg even with such a short post.
JordanA24- Definitely /outie.
Kinetic- /outie. I doubt he would have validly claimed scum.
klebian- /outie, based on inactivity.
mnowax- /outie, based on inactivity.
oEJo- Has kept up with the game, and even asked the mod to clarify something. Probably /innie.
OhGodMyLife- 1 post. /outie.
PokerFace- Has been planning and suspecting. /innie.
Rishi- I do believe he really is an /outie.
skitzer- Very active. /innie, methinks.
Thestatusquo- Well, let's see. He's shot three people so far this round. Probably /outie.
Thyroidectomy- Only post: "I like the town to win games. I'm an /out". Yes, he is an /outie.
Vaughn- Another one-poster. /outie.
xyzzy- Not much to say. /outie, most likely.
YagamiLight- Seems to care about wasted bullets and such. /innie. (Also, <3 Death Note.)
YvonneSeer- One post. Shot Jordan. /outie or bare-minimum scum.

I mostly made this list for my own benefit, and I thought I might as well post it. It's brief and uninformative, but those are my basic analysis results. So, I ended up narrowing it down to about 13 people who I think are most likely to be /innies (counting myself and Jordan). However, the scum are probably among the people I've determined to be /outies. Hmm...

[YagamiLight]

So, would asking the person who lost their shot yesterday to claim a good idea?

Even should we ask there is no way to know for sure the person who claimed is the real deal and not a /out pretending to be the one who completed the shot. Not to mention that we will probably get claims from the one /in who did shoot, any scum who pretended to shoot, and /out who pretended to shoot.