Adn it turned out the role names were all from a game that the mod didn't even tell us about, so when we fake claimed, the town could see we were lying. I didn't like that game. 
Mostly I just want to know why such a minor point is any part of your argument whatsoever on page 38. Yeah, it's ok to talk about it (although not bandwagon it) when there's nothing else to go on, but it's page 38. We have PLENTY to talk about.Guardian wrote:Well, Gorrad, at what time in the game are you referring to? When I first brought it up, I thought it was the best thing we had in the game.
Now, I look as it as adding to the fact that Iammars's play has been rather lurky and not town-helpful. At this point, it is part of my suspicion for Iammars, not the totality.
A couple posts lately, when Guardian tosses out Thesp-Thok scum possibilityThestatusquo wrote:I too noted that, though I am not sure what my read on Thesp is. (leaning on agreeing with guardian, though.)
Post 543 when the KScope wagon starts rolling.Thestatusquo wrote:I could see thesp thok, but not nearly as strongly as you are positing it. In addition, I think it's way too early to be looking for scumpairs. Lets just find one scum first, K? Then we can focus on their partners.
There's actually less of this in your posts than I expected, but it's still there to some extent. Actually going over this makes me feel a bit better about you.Thestatusquo wrote:I do like votes on kscope myself, as well. I would caution however that SirT always seems to play this way on day one. Kscope as well, even, so never mind I don't know how I actually feel about that.
Twomz, the only person I have ever actually seen that meta work on was creampuffeater.
Nothing of the sort: it merely suggests Thesp is more careful and covert than Guardian and TSQ. Scumbags are rarely this blatant and if they are, I doubt more than one scum are going to apply the same dangerous strategy this early in the game.Thok wrote:I think my repeated disapproval of a Thesp wagon should be clear. He hasn't had any of the sort of kind of wishy-washiness that I see in Guardian/TSQ in terms of choosing their targets (take look at Guardian/TSQ's posts and you'll see a bunch of "Eh, I could see X as scum" comments that never get followed up on unless X is actually being wagonned; this suggests that Thesp actually has standards for his bandwagons while Guardian/TSQ are scum trying to get whatever wagon they can take.
You do realize that the sort of thing I'm pointing out isn't "blatant" at all?Mgm wrote:Nothing of the sort: it merely suggests Thesp is more careful and covert than Guardian and TSQ. Scumbags are rarely this blatant and if they are, I doubt more than one scum are going to apply the same dangerous strategy this early in the game.
Your OMGUS has been noted.Xtoxm wrote:I don't like the way he's trying to get Guardian lynched despite the claim I think his roleclaim fits and guardian looks town and now he's accused me too.hasdgfas wrote:Xtoxm wrote:I think Thok is scumvote Thok
Mind elaborating at all?
How is the second quote at all "wishy washy?" I grant the possibility of a thok-thesp scumpair, and say that I don't think it's hugely likely... and then I go on to take the definitive stance that we shouldn't be looking for scumpairs day one.Thok wrote:TSQ-here's what I've seen that I would consider "wishy-washy"
Post 245, when there's a big Thesp/Guardian argument going on, with people generally being more suspicious of Thesp than Guardian.
A couple posts lately, when Guardian tosses out Thesp-Thok scum possibilityThestatusquo wrote:I too noted that, though I am not sure what my read on Thesp is. (leaning on agreeing with guardian, though.)
Post 543 when the KScope wagon starts rolling.Thestatusquo wrote:I could see thesp thok, but not nearly as strongly as you are positing it. In addition, I think it's way too early to be looking for scumpairs. Lets just find one scum first, K? Then we can focus on their partners.
There's actually less of this in your posts than I expected, but it's still there to some extent. Actually going over this makes me feel a bit better about you.Thestatusquo wrote:I do like votes on kscope myself, as well. I would caution however that SirT always seems to play this way on day one. Kscope as well, even, so never mind I don't know how I actually feel about that.
Twomz, the only person I have ever actually seen that meta work on was creampuffeater.