PBPA of shaft.ed
0: joins NLU
4-5: Says he "doesn't trustgossip" (pun?). Asks who else is unteamed, and selects TJM instead because TJM has a "cool name".
I'm trying to work out whether or not this is potentially meaningful. @Shaft.ed: Could you explain why you rejected trustgossip?
11: Describes Adel following me with "O Captain! My Captain" as a 'convenient method of BWing'
12: Thoughts so far:
Adel - Doesn't like her team-based BWing
(Begs the question as to why)
Armlx for his attention to BW size
TJM for saying one vote can amount to pressure
15: Votes Adel because "I'm not liking some of your choices and reasoning thus far"
Very vague
. Doesn't like Dean saying he doesn't know where to place his vote since he has seen it as scum trying to look active
Where?
18: After I said that Adel just seems to be stirring the pot as usual, shafted says he meta'd her and found she plays like this before.
19: Explains that he meant unorthodox, not 'unbridled BWing"
20: References Adel self L-1 voting.
22: Admits he was wrong to say Adel often plays like this
24: Explains he was trying to determine why Adel was BWing.
25: Notes Pooky's inflammatory play
26: More (justified) strikes at Pooky's behaviour. Asks armlx to elaborate on his case against shaft and to compare shaft.ed to TJM.
33: Thinks armlx is scummy for pretending to mimic Adel and notes that he misread his vc and that scum tend to act less rationally when they confuse the two
Really?
Doesn't understand why TG unvoted to make TJM talk.
34: Scumdar, only of team LU.
1) Armlx: Attacks for his reluctance to be third, his firm declarations of alignments, and fanning with Pooky
Decent enough attack of armlx thus far, though he does tie it to Pooky
2) Pooky: Flaming fans and very little content
True
3) Erg0: Lurker who posted a lot then slunk off
4) Dean: Total lukrer
5) TG: Doing a good job of scumhunting
38: Doesn't like the attacks against me because my play is same as usual. Makes a critique of Pooky's arguments against me. Says he isn't liking armlx's recent posting. Doesn't like Adel accusing me for being scummier than Pooky when Adel originated the attacks on TJM. Thinks TG is an ass-kisser.
39: Notes a significant contradiciton in TG criticising me for pushing against TJM when he had done it himself.
41: Disputes armlx's CKD case.
42: TG is the only LU he thinks is town. He thinks CKD and I am playing same as usual. THinks armlx is not used to CKD's style. Adel as wild card. Thinks TJM is avoiding having to play.
49: Thinks Adel's interrogating has the potential to result in people slipping under pressure, that he doesn't like what appeared to be my effective ignoring of the lynch results, and that he TG's MegaFoS is just poor play.
50: Further criticism of Pooky
55: Case against Pooky. Suspicion initially provoked by Pooky's pot-stirring. Doesn't think Pooky's argument against evidence was pro-town. Says it was odd Pooky kept his vote on TJM whilst attacking shaft.ed. Then notes that Pooky also had his vote on TJM while the pressure mounted. Then he criticises the "frankly speaking" string again.
56: Thinks Pooky is consistently scummy and TG has a few slips.
67: Explains that he thought armlx's "intentionally acting scummy" was garbage. Says he was not going hard at armlx because Pooky was scummier
70: "having a conversation with pooky has felt like trying to nail Jello to a wall for me." unvotes pooky
74: Votes TG
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I'm MUCH more persuaded by the TG case than this. shaft.ed's play has been fairly consistent and has reasonably explained the problems I previously raised.
