Open 59 - Daytalk 12! (Game Over) before 545

[Phate]

Wait a second, we're at lylo, aren't we?

Vote: Adel

What's the case against me again?

[JDodge]

Phate, Adel: Votes off.

I don't really think that either of you are scum. I think Adel's logic (assuming I'm guessing what it is properly) is flawed and that Phate is not smart enough to do something simple like read the fucking rules.

[Adel]

Phate, Adel: Votes off.

I don't really think that either of you are scum. I think Adel's logic (assuming I'm guessing what it is properly) is flawed and that Phate is not smart enough to do something simple like read the fucking rules.

Phate is smart enough, and he made a huge slip, and I'm not about to let him off of the hook.

Who did he exchange pm's with during the night again?

[Xtoxm]

Phate, Adel: Votes off.

I don't really think that either of you are scum. I think Adel's logic (assuming I'm guessing what it is properly) is flawed and that Phate is not smart enough to do something simple like read the fucking rules.

Phate is smart enough, and he made a huge slip, and I'm not about to let him off of the hook.

Who did he exchange pm's with during the night again?

He said he never did, you are putting words in his mouth, and that's scummy IMO.

vote Adel

cos i'm scum wagoning.

[Incognito]

It seems pretty clear to me that one of you two (either Adel or Phate) is scum. I just wouldn't expect two townies to be voting for each other like this in a LyLo situation. I think Phate's being earnest here though while Adel's intention seem malicious so...

Vote: Adel

[Guardian]

vote: Adel

[Xtoxm]

Yays.

[Incognito]

Nicely done.

[Adel]

I guess neither Pate nor I were scum. darn. Sorry Phate, I think the is the second time I've been totally wrong about you.

[Incognito]

Damn, Adel. You're quick.

[Xtoxm]

Damn, Adel. You're quick.

We knew you were online...That's why we voted you over Phate.

[Guardian]

Go team .

GG guys.

Sorry Mizzy -- and kab -- I hope you still keep up with mafia after this! (I PM'd extensively with both of them and I'm pretty sure they trusted me ;X)

Thanks Oman for moding. Thanks scum partners for being totally inconspicuous.

And this setup is definitely balanced towards scum; it is like mountainous, but 3:9 instead of 2:10 and scum get to daytalk.

PPE: LOL damn, she was quick, happy I suggested we do her and not Phate, she might have unvoted, even.

[Adel]

I would have... I was watching for a quick wagon to develop.

[Guardian]

I wasn't here Night 1, Night 2 Nab was an obvious, obvious choice with Adel assuming he was town and no one being suspicious of him; Night 3 we all wanted different things, Mizzy from Incog, Jdodge from me, vollkan from Xtoxm, but we decided vollkan is just too good a scum hunter and decided to kill him.

The logs I have are:

incognito -- http://www.quicktopic.com/41/H/L7kAzpQn4T65

kab -- http://www.quicktopic.com/41/H/vTLD54wDThb

nabnab -- http://www.quicktopic.com/41/H/ExkBkkV3psVh


I also talked a lot with Adel & Mizzy but we used PM not quicktopic.
Additionally, we PM'd a lot right now to set up the quick lynch.

[Guardian]

I would have... I was watching for a quick wagon to develop.

LOL, I called that to Incognito over IM. You're tricky Adel. Very tricky.

[Incognito]

Xtoxm and Guardian, thanks for subbing in too! After Sir Tornado and Primate left the game, I was pretty nervous being the only scum amongst arguing townies.

But yeah, this game is definitely heavily scum-favored and might have been a little different with a cop around and a godfather like Adel suggested. I chose scotmany12 as the NK during night 1 because he hadn't said anything within the thread. I figured that killing anyone else might have given the town some information about who is or isn't scum.

Thanks, Oman for modding.

[Xtoxm]

Other than 1 PM to Phate, in which he didn't reply so I assumed he thought what I said to be scummy, just talked with scum about kills.

[Guardian]

Yeah, Xtoxm, lol, Incognito and I PM'd a bit during the game, we didn't include you so it wouldn't look like all three of us were plotting together xD. Sorry for missing you out on the daytalk xD.

[Adel]

I would have... I was watching for a quick wagon to develop.

LOL, I called that to Incognito over IM. You're tricky Adel. Very tricky.

obviously not. I was hoping to catch scum, not get lynched and lose the game.

[Incognito]

I'm really surprised you decided to vote so quick Adel. What was your logic?

[Mizzy]

Sorry Mizzy -- and kab -- I hope you still keep up with mafia after this! (I PM'd extensively with both of them and I'm pretty sure they trusted me ;X)

Oh, you will get yours, Mister, you just wait

Trust me, I won't stop playing ^^ I may be hormonal but I am stubborn and self-righteous as well!

[Adel]

I'm really surprised you decided to vote so quick Adel. What was your logic?

we were hosed, so identifying scum trying to join a wagon for a quick lynch would be our best chance. When nobody joined me on the Phate wagon I figured that he must be scum.

[Mizzy]

I'm really surprised you decided to vote so quick Adel. What was your logic?

we were hosed, so identifying scum trying to join a wagon for a quick lynch would be our best chance. When nobody joined me on the Phate wagon I figured that he must be scum.

No worries, Adel, you're right, we were pretty fucked and I wasn't confident enough to vote because of how wrong I'd been earlier

[Adel]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... start=1900 is where some of us are talking about how to revise this setup for another, more balanced, run.

[vollkan]

Good game guys. I enjoyed this one and was sad to go.