Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[Battle Mage]

^same lol (about the quick reply button)

[armlx]

Yes! New page! Quick reply is back on the screen!

The 1 interesting thing I've noticed from that chart so far is antithesis has yet to make a vote.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Nobody quote the table or we are going to have a problem.

[skitzer]

Popular Lynch ideas I see most likely to be scum: tlp, Lloyd, and WhoMe?

Popular Lynch ideas I see most unlikely to be scum: Charity and TSN

just my opinion. Therefore, for now, I'm going back to

vote: tlp

[Battle Mage]

Popular Lynch ideas I see most likely to be scum: tlp, Lloyd, and WhoMe?

Popular Lynch ideas I see most unlikely to be scum: Charity and TSN

just my opinion. Therefore, for now, I'm going back to

vote: tlp

Yo Skitzer, can you please do me a PBPA of Killa Seven?

And you can also explain why you are only willing to vote for so called 'popular lynch' candidates.

BM

[skitzer]

Well, Killa Seven's first post seems like a way to validate his somewhat lurkiness, and then from there, most of his points consist of either 1 sentence retorts that make no sense if you just read his posts, or a quote and then a restating or maybe a minor tweakage of facts. Now, from my point of view, not scum hunting isn't a scum tell to me (I've been incorrectly lynched for it), so it doesn't really hit me. I'm just not sure why we're are so much focus on him.

Originally I had my vote on tlp, and I just took it off because the game had gone a little crazy. I see Charity and TSN as a wrong lynch due to their current playstyles.

[Battle Mage]

Im sorry. Ill be a bit more specific. Ill quote posts of his which I find scummy, and you can do your best to explain them away. Then i'll explain why i think they are scummy, which means my opinions go down on paper aswell-its a Win-Win

1.

alright, issue solved.

the next person who talks about the cult recruiter as if its going to help the town to do so is going to be personally murdered.

so your basically saying your either scum or a sk? and you can kill someone..

vote rosso carne

2.

. Right now, he is a contributing, pro-town player. He's almost confirmed himself as town by claiming miller straight-off.

eh not entirely true making miller vlaims doesnt mean you arent realy scum. btw i dont think hes scum i was just pointing that out

3.

Farside. vote for Killa 7 plz.

kthxbai

Okay

Unvote: Vote Killa seven

wow this is a earie post.. sum buddies? and why did u pick me from the bandwagon.. u vote hope more than anyone else in this game bm.. smh

Those 3 will do for now. I'll leave the other posts which are merely exhibitions of lurking in plain sight, as you have already acknowledged them.

BM

[skitzer]

My wordage is in

pretty green, and bolded

Im sorry. Ill be a bit more specific. Ill quote posts of his which I find scummy, and you can do your best to explain them away. Then i'll explain why i think they are scummy, which means my opinions go down on paper aswell-its a Win-Win

1.

alright, issue solved.

the next person who talks about the cult recruiter as if its going to help the town to do so is going to be personally murdered.

so your basically saying your either scum or a sk? and you can kill someone..

vote rosso carne

I believe I thought the exact same thing, but then I played with rosso in another game and realized this was just his playstyle. Therefore, I don't find this very scummy.

2.

. Right now, he is a contributing, pro-town player. He's almost confirmed himself as town by claiming miller straight-off.

eh not entirely true making miller vlaims doesnt mean you arent realy scum. btw i dont think hes scum i was just pointing that out

Hmm...is it contradictory. But could explain how exactly you find that scummy, because I'm not exactly sure I get it.

3.

Farside. vote for Killa 7 plz.

kthxbai

Okay

Unvote: Vote Killa seven

wow this is a earie post.. sum buddies? and why did u pick me from the bandwagon.. u vote hope more than anyone else in this game bm.. smh

This seems like a mixture of OMGUS and not realizing sarcasm and cheek. This is probably the most scummy out of the three.

Those 3 will do for now. I'll leave the other posts which are merely exhibitions of lurking in plain sight, as you have already acknowledged them.

BM

I'm sorry I didn't do that. I'm just not a fan of those types of posts. It makes me want to throw up knowing that I just made one.

[Rosso Carne]

wordage is not a word

ill be gone all next week.

[Imat]

...Can we please stop the randomness we've fallen back into? BM had a reason to vote lloyd, to try and catch Scum. killa fell into his trap, as did two others, but BM thought killa to be the most Scummy. So he voted killa, simple as that. Its also possible, knowing BM's other trap, that asking farside to vote killa was another trap. Perhaps he was looking at farside to see if he'd be easy to sway the vote of, perhaps marking him as someone who wants a quick lynch, somebody usually anti-town.

Thats was kind of how I took it, though BM may have had other reasons. Scum won't ask each other for votes, and even if they did, they wouldn't vote the same way when asked. Number one way to expose yourself as Scum: Vote with Scum or give your vote to the quickest Lynch.

You, my friend, are VERY perceptive.

Which goes against everything he has done so far. Good learner.

I don't know what to say to this...I think BM was being sarcastic, but that could just be me being paranoid. I think armlx was being sarcastic as well, but not so much jokingly but in a "That may point him out as scum" way. Again, could be paranoia, I have trouble knowing when people are being sarcastic when praising me...Character flaw, if you will.

Anyways, Lloyd's vote counter was both overly large and underly telling. The fact that he bothered to make the list gives me a slightly greater Town read from him, but the fact that it wouldn't tell us anything unless somebody had voted with every single wagon doesn't really give cause to post it, giving me cause to suspect Lloyd of trying to appear a hunter while posting nothing of value. Pretty much eliminates the alignment of the entire post.

Rosso still doesn't make large posts, I don't understand why the pressure left him. Because he didn't post enough of an explanation to make a wagon interesting?

Still, I don't really know about the killa wagon. Perhaps I just missed something. I'll have to reread his posts or something. Or, if anybody else wants to explain their suspicions, I'll look into those specifically. Either way I'm going to reread him, so I'll get back to you all.

[farside22]

@Imat: There is a nice post by BM if you just take a look.

Fade scene to a desk. You see a female prone, her head is on the desk and she looks dead. Someone checks for breathing. She looks up with a glazed look and droll coming out of her mouth.
"What is wrong?" ask BM
She stutters "so---much---stupidity" then her head starts banging on the desk. "must -----relieve----pain"

[Battle Mage]

...Can we please stop the randomness we've fallen back into? BM had a reason to vote lloyd, to try and catch Scum. killa fell into his trap, as did two others, but BM thought killa to be the most Scummy. So he voted killa, simple as that. Its also possible, knowing BM's other trap, that asking farside to vote killa was another trap. Perhaps he was looking at farside to see if he'd be easy to sway the vote of, perhaps marking him as someone who wants a quick lynch, somebody usually anti-town.

Thats was kind of how I took it, though BM may have had other reasons. Scum won't ask each other for votes, and even if they did, they wouldn't vote the same way when asked. Number one way to expose yourself as Scum: Vote with Scum or give your vote to the quickest Lynch.

You, my friend, are VERY perceptive.

Which goes against everything he has done so far. Good learner.

I don't know what to say to this...I think BM was being sarcastic, but that could just be me being paranoid. I think armlx was being sarcastic as well, but not so much jokingly but in a "That may point him out as scum" way. Again, could be paranoia, I have trouble knowing when people are being sarcastic when praising me...Character flaw, if you will.

Rofl. Yep i agree with the paranoid comment. I was actually being complimentary-as you basically read my mind.

Anyways, Lloyd's vote counter was both overly large and underly telling. The fact that he bothered to make the list gives me a slightly greater Town read from him, but the fact that it wouldn't tell us anything unless somebody had voted with every single wagon doesn't really give cause to post it, giving me cause to suspect Lloyd of trying to appear a hunter while posting nothing of value. Pretty much eliminates the alignment of the entire post.

Rosso still doesn't make large posts, I don't understand why the pressure left him. Because he didn't post enough of an explanation to make a wagon interesting?

Still, I don't really know about the killa wagon. Perhaps I just missed something. I'll have to reread his posts or something. Or, if anybody else wants to explain their suspicions, I'll look into those specifically. Either way I'm going to reread him, so I'll get back to you all.

I look forward to reading it. (not sarcasm)

[Antithesis]

Yes! New page! Quick reply is back on the screen!

The 1 interesting thing I've noticed from that chart so far is antithesis has yet to make a vote.

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Yes! New page! Quick reply is back on the screen!

The 1 interesting thing I've noticed from that chart so far is antithesis has yet to make a vote.

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

You have a point, scumtells haven't come out, but I haven't seen you posting very much, and we need more serious conversation for scumtells to come out.

[VanDamien]

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

Why are you waiting for someone to do your job as a townie? Is it because you're not town, and need a strong BW to get behind?

[dahill1]

hey everyone i'm the replacement
can somone tell me briefly why everyone is voting for lloyd and/or the "highlights" so far

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

hey everyone i'm the replacement
can somone tell me briefly why everyone is voting for lloyd and/or the "highlights" so far

I'll tell you, the highlights are obvious if you read pages 1-30 along the way you will also learn why people are voting for Lloyd

[Battle Mage]

Yes! New page! Quick reply is back on the screen!

The 1 interesting thing I've noticed from that chart so far is antithesis has yet to make a vote.

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

HoS: AntiThesis

Scum Slip Up Alert! Sirens! Big flashing lights!
lol

Why are you simply waiting for someone to make a case, which you can hop onto, as opposed to making a case YOURSELF. If you are town, get some fecking motivation. Your laziness isnt going to help the game. If you are scum, i look forward to an impending town victory. You seriously think we're just going to let you get away with tagging along to others logic?

Conservative scum is my favourite

BM

[Battle Mage]

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

Why are you waiting for someone to do your job as a townie? Is it because you're not town, and need a strong BW to get behind?

townie points for also spotting this

@Dahill- Hi there! To be honest there isnt much pressing that you need to know about now. As far as im aware, not everyone is voting for Lloyd, nor is he about to get lynched. All that you need to do before you get on with your read of the game, is vote for Killa Seven so we can put a scummy guy under some pressure. You cool with that?

BM

[dahill1]

haha well i'll read first then vote

[Battle Mage]

why? read through Killa's posts, and then tell me you dont think he is worth some pressure?

[curiouskarmadog]

it has been well over a month and we are on page 30, we are going around in circles and we have a ton of information under our belts...I for one dont really know who is scum and my vote is based on little scraps of scumminess. Antithesis is right, we need someone to lay out a case on someone else, but there just isnt any solid information Day 1 to really push a case. soo,

Mod, I think it is time to set a deadline!

[JordanA24]

Vote Count Updated at Post 735,

dahill1 replaces Charity, andersonw has agreed to continue posting, still looking for replacements for GSGold and Inconito

EDIT: I think I agree with those discussing a deadline, due to the current length of Day 1, but I also feel the game is fairly active as well, so I will set a deadline for 2 weeks from now for

Saturday 22nd March 9.00pm GMT

.

If anyone has any objections to either the time of the deadline or the deadline itself, please post it in bold to make sure I don't miss it, thanks!

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Stuff.

HoS: AntiThesis

Scum Slip Up Alert! Sirens! Big flashing lights!
lol

Why are you simply waiting for someone to make a case, which you can hop onto, as opposed to making a case YOURSELF. If you are town, get some fecking motivation. Your laziness isnt going to help the game. If you are scum, i look forward to an impending town victory. You seriously think we're just going to let you get away with tagging along to others logic?

Conservative scum is my favourite

BM

This is true, but no real evidence against him, but to go along with pressure on killa I'll go ahead

Vote: killa seven

for now...

[Battle Mage]

Hmm i dont agree with the deadline concept at this stage, but as 2 weeks is quite a long time, i'll concede for now, as long as we get somewhere in the next week.

BM