armlx wrote:Blaze:
You pick up on things like TSS saying you need to die, yet suggest bad lynch plans. Thats the contradiction that gets me the most.
One thing is not really related to another.
I said "claimed townies should die so they arent recruited". There were no claimed townies at the moment, it is something that would only happen later in the day, had time to be discussed and so. I was not trying to convince anyone to lynch an innocent, and it is not such an absurd suggestion that only a cultist would do. I keep hitting this point, it just happened in my last game. And at the moment I made the suggestion, I didnt remember the alarmist. But I see now it is wrong, it really doesnt help the town. It is a mistake. It is an error about "whether a lynched townie is better than a recruited one"
TSS says "he should die for giving a bad suggestion and being the second in a wagon". When you vote someone, you are not saying the person needs to die. YOu might just be investigating, putting pressure, etc. When you say "he needs to die" its like "its over, you cant possibly get out of this, EVERYBODY VOTE HIM". Seems to me like someone rushing to lynch someone right away, over little evidence.
I hope this is my last about OMGUS, cause I really have nothing better to say than this: believe it or not, I would have voted (with a "sounded weird" meaning, and not a "lynch him right away" meaning as he did) TSS for that way of speaking whoever he was accusing. I dont think TSS is definetly guilty, but, again, believe it or not, if I live long enough in the game, my bad feeling over this wont go away if/when he unvotes me. Not saying he will never be able to say anything to convince me he is town. Just that this phrase will always seem, at least, misplaced to me.