Before I do my next PBPA, something which has come up in House Mafia, which just finished, is what shaft.ed terms the "Vollkan effect" - namely that my use of PBPAs has the effect of causing other people to rely on me as the "Cliff's Notes" version of the game. I don't like this because I need argument in order to test any ideas I get. I am slightly worried that my actions in this game may be having this effect. The point of these PBPAs is to incite debate, not to educate the lazy.
In order to get around that, I am going to make this more case-oriented than summary-oriented. So that you can't get away with just reading me.
PBPA of Panzerjager
1: Tells egr to stop spouting stupid ideas.
2: Votes Fonz for writing egr off and voting somebody for attacking egr
I don't see how Fonz's actions are scummy. He votes someone for assuming that anti-town =/= scum, and it was reasonable to assume he was a newbie (He had townsperson under his name).
5: Votes Mills for advocating the lynch of anti-towns
HA! Irony. You call Fonz scum because he voted Bookitty for voting egruntz for being anti-town, when you yourself just voted Mills for pushing against DS.
11: Is against Xyl's proposal to lynch the anti-town
But doesn't vote him...interesting
12: Votes Mills and FoSes hasdfas for a page of distancing (it was distancing because it was "non-consequential"
This argument is crap. Obvious distancing involves kid-glove attacks - designed to show suspicion but not to risk a lynch.
13: After being attacked for the issue I italicised, he then says that the very fact there was no attacking (ie. no 'distancing') is what makes it suspicious.
How is this scummy at all?!
14: Suspicion list:
Panzer wrote: Mills
Egruntz
Cow
The Fonz
Disciple Slayer
Patch15
the other lurkers that I haven't mentioned
everyone else
Elias
Me
15: FoSes DE; it's unclear why "I haven't really liked what he has had to say, but i think it's semantics cause the idea isn't scummy just the words. "
16: "I think egruntz is town. I really do."
Your suspicion list from just two days ago says otherwise
His top contender for scum is Mills.
20: The meltdown confirms he is scummy.
How?
21: More anti-Mills. Doesn't think DS deserves more votes.
27: Attacks CKD for
- a) Lurking - Not a scumtell
b) Over-reacting - Not a scumtell
c) OMGUSing - Depends how its done. And you don't analyse the how
31: Again attacks CKD for being over-defensive, saying it shows a guilty conscience
Bullshit
32: Jumps onto Egr in agreement with Bookitty
What happened to "I think egruntz is town. I really do."?
42: Votes Phate for thinking Egr would spill
Scummy how?
55: Thinks OGML and Snaps are scummy, with no reasons
62: Swaps to snaps because OGML seems somewhat sincere
67: Votes OGML for the "sake of a lynch"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Please respond to all that is italicised.