My observation is that Catfish voted without giving a reason (in his vote post), and then shadow hopped on without even trying to justify his hop on. I would accuse them of continuing RVS, but they have both made comments about being out of RVS. Catfish is voting for Tragedy for fluff and such (am i reading this right?), and Shadow has not offered a reason?
So, Cat is voting a weak scum tell, and Shadow is sheeping.
Cat is voting a scum tell, makes me think he's not scum at this point.
Don't think Shadow is scum. If he was, i gotta believe he would have voted a larger wagon.
Also, not sure if Shadow calling SH a newb is flavor or serious....
Furthermore, since i saw Shadow's proposed avi for Catfish several,
several
times, i propse this instead:
pedit:@Duplicity: Yeah, looks like I was right, wasn't I? I'm gonna be honest. I underestimated you, and (nearly) paid the price. I'm not gonna call you out on my meta read, since I did that last game and allowed scum to play me into their hands.