Open 879: Fire and More Fire [game over]

[sheepsaysmeep]

everyone here is so friendly ive never gotten so many hi's

[Doctor Drew]

everyone here is so friendly ive never gotten so many hi's

Fuck of Sheep you piece of garbage.

Does that make you feel more comfortable lol.

[Merlyn]

Okay, here's my readslist:

Spoiler: Wall O'Text Incoming

Osuka- town. I like the push on towl/Drew, and I’ve found that I tend to agree anytime they write ‘????????????’ about a post. I also don’t believe they were dumbtelling when they forgot the game setup.

Ausuka- town. Her argument and visible frustration with Bingle’s POV read genuine to me. Also some good questioning like in 607640.

The Bulge- townlean. Bulge laid out their case on Bingle very clearly and I can see their process in it, I find this authentic. It is looking a little tunnely but I don’t scumread a tunnel.

Firebringer- townlean. I may not agree with the Bingle case, but I think it’s an authentic case that FB actually believes.

Bingle- slight townlean. I don’t agree with the Ausuka case but I appreciate the case they made. The main reason I lean town though is bc his wagon is not a good one.

Meuh- ….town??? the slot I’m least certain of. But when I read her ISO I feel like the thing that pinged me is one thing vs. a lot of posts I agree with.

Invisibility- I lean slight town here. Viz has put her money where her mouth is and voted when things ping her, then returned to the bingle vote. The thing that keeps me from placing her higher is that I don’t know why she’s sheeping firebringer, and when people have asked she’s only made jokes about it. I mean I giggled at the jokes, but I don’t like that there’s no reason.

Sheepsaysmeep- null, will have to see more to know

Black- null. She’s asking good questions, I like her boldness with her votes. I have heard she’s really good at looking towny while scum but I have no personal experience with that, and I don’t want to fall down the WIFOM hole. The biggest thing that gives me pause here is the weird read Bella gave about her.

Skygazer- null, leaning scum. My genuine like of Sky makes me want her to be town, but the iso is pretty much all jokes. The one thing they’ve done for game-solving was the Auskua white knight thing, but she hasn’t followed up with any thoughts on what came from that.

Umlaut- slight scumlean. This is such a flip for me, I’ve been reading Umlaut as town for most of the game, but in ISO I realized their Ausuka vote is still based on this post 407 and they’ve never updated or revised it. I don’t like jumping on the cook wagon- the cook wagon is dookie.


Doctor Drew- Slight scumlean. I didn’t love towel’s posts but I see that Drew hasn’t really done anything to ping me. The signaling madness is very classic Drew to me, and he’s done it as town in every game I’ve been in with him. The thing that keeps me from moving him higher is the Whiskey Pocket, “I like Umlaut and I like Bingle” is not a good reason to sheep to me. I mean, I like you and that doesn’t mean I think I should automatically sheep you.


Radical Rat - leaning scum. I actually had this general vibe that they were town, but when I ISO’d I couldn’t figure out what led me to think that. They say their vote on Drew is because they’ve taken FB’s case against Bingle and repurposed it to Drew? 429 I also find the early compromise lim talk and the cook vote to be dookie.

Bellaphant-scumlean. It’s a small ISO, but I think her saying that the Black ‘wagon’ was bad is so odd considering there was no wagon and I really didn’t like her answer to Ausuka’s question in 631. I have heard the exact opposite about Black than what she posted here, and I notice Black has asked about it too with no response as of yet.

So yeah VOTE: Bella

[sheepsaysmeep]

everyone here is so friendly ive never gotten so many hi's

Fuck of Sheep you piece of garbage.

Does that make you feel more comfortable lol.

wow that feels more like forum mafia

[Doctor Drew]

everyone here is so friendly ive never gotten so many hi's

Fuck of Sheep you piece of garbage.

Does that make you feel more comfortable lol.

wow that feels more like forum mafia

It is like the partner you know is bad for you, but you can't quit them.

[sheepsaysmeep]

I think readlists like the one merlyn just posted are very +town

[Doctor Drew]

Don't be a hater because I am not sheeping you Merlyn.

If there are players that I like, and that I feel somewhat confident are not scum, there is a decent chance I will sheep them, at least for a bit.

Also you just lost your opportunity to be a part of the Whiskey Pocket

[The Bulge]

i tried reading new posts today and have been wanting to give the rest of the thread a reread but everything is just immediately leaking out of my brain today so ill try again tomorrow

(not a prod dodge btw)

[The Bulge]

I think readlists like the one merlyn just posted are very +town

what quality of merlyn's readslist do you tr

[osuka]

if you're town, why would scum not jump on your wagon?

I don't think scum is the majority of my wagon, and I don't think scum is going to want to stick their necks out for me. Hence...

i’m hurt that nobody told me it was goddamn fucking amateur hour

VOTE: bingle

[The Bulge]

I think readlists like the one merlyn just posted are very +town

what quality of merlyn's readslist do you tr

sorry that wording is dumb

i mean why "readslists like the one merlyn just posted" and not simply "the readslist merlyn just posted"

[sheepsaysmeep]

I think readlists like the one merlyn just posted are very +town

what quality of merlyn's readslist do you tr

it's like the types of explanations that are there. like I havent read this mafia game I have no clue how good the explanations are. but theyre very free-flowing and un-calculated and feel genuinely off the top of the head

tonally

[osuka]

unless i missed something - why are you offering reads on the people on your wagon? what is this?

Why would I not analyze the biggest wagon as literally the only person who knows for sure it's on town? What? Did you get into SG's acid, osuka?

that post is just sort of shit and it makes no sense to me. if your analysis of the biggest wagon on none other than yourself is “everyone’s town, they have good reasons, fucking rainbows and sunshine”, isn’t that just one step short of a scumclaim? you somehow simultaneously made yourself look worse, the wagon look better, and did all of that while inexplicably adding zero meaningful content other than the fact that you clearly don’t have good (or real?) reads on any of the people voting you

[osuka]

it’s t-t-t-t-t-tunnel time!!!
VOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingleVOTE: bingle

[sheepsaysmeep]

I think readlists like the one merlyn just posted are very +town

what quality of merlyn's readslist do you tr

sorry that wording is dumb

i mean why "readslists like the one merlyn just posted" and not simply "the readslist merlyn just posted"

I am basing this off of a lazy general understanding that I thought applied the moment I saw it. "big posts that feel like that, that cover every player with a couple lines just like that, have appeared in my forum mafia experience and have been town".

Rather than, "I spent critical thinking and time pondering on Merlyn's post here and came to this conclusion"

idk

what was the purpose of this question

what do you think about Merlyn's post

[Merlyn]

Don't be a hater because I am not sheeping you Merlyn.

If there are players that I like, and that I feel somewhat confident are not scum, there is a decent chance I will sheep them, at least for a bit.

Also you just lost your opportunity to be a part of the Whiskey Pocket

Well jokes on you bc I prefer bourbon

[Doctor Drew]

Don't be a hater because I am not sheeping you Merlyn.

If there are players that I like, and that I feel somewhat confident are not scum, there is a decent chance I will sheep them, at least for a bit.

Also you just lost your opportunity to be a part of the Whiskey Pocket

Well jokes on you bc I prefer bourbon

I have some bad news for you then......

Also, Sheep is town.....and I forget who they even replaced!

[Merlyn]

Don't be a hater because I am not sheeping you Merlyn.

If there are players that I like, and that I feel somewhat confident are not scum, there is a decent chance I will sheep them, at least for a bit.

Also you just lost your opportunity to be a part of the Whiskey Pocket

Well jokes on you bc I prefer bourbon

I have some bad news for you then......

Also, Sheep is town.....and I forget who they even replaced!

I had to google that. Is everything whiskey??!?!

Why is Sheep town?

[Bingle]

unless i missed something - why are you offering reads on the people on your wagon? what is this?

Why would I not analyze the biggest wagon as literally the only person who knows for sure it's on town? What? Did you get into SG's acid, osuka?

that post is just sort of shit and it makes no sense to me. if your analysis of the biggest wagon on none other than yourself is “everyone’s town, they have good reasons, fucking rainbows and sunshine”, isn’t that just one step short of a scumclaim? you somehow simultaneously made yourself look worse, the wagon look better, and did all of that while inexplicably adding zero meaningful content other than the fact that you clearly don’t have good (or real?) reads on any of the people voting you

[Bingle]

I am a very intelligent player and i disagree mr mech player

[Invisibility]

Invisibility- I lean slight town here. Viz has put her money where her mouth is and voted when things ping her, then returned to the bingle vote. The thing that keeps me from placing her higher is that I don’t know why she’s sheeping firebringer, and when people have asked she’s only made jokes about it. I mean I giggled at the jokes, but I don’t like that there’s no reason.

hey I have reasons now. I explain one in like 713. Also I agree with Osuka's 737

[Bingle]

Oh, sorry. I ignored:

what exactly makes it the worst vote then?

Cause I'd already answered it and assumed you'd just keep reading.

you say it's the worst vote on you, so do you refute my reasoning as i just explained it? i think my vote on the wagon has the most substance to it by far, what makes it worse than a purported omgus vote, a bad meta case, and a sheep?

Worst in the sense that of the four votes, I see the most scum intention behind it, which is not much. OMGUS votes are generally NAI, I think Vizzy's blind sheeping is actually pretty towny, and I think Firebringers shitcase is actually very towny.

[Invisibility]

Oh, sorry. I ignored:

what exactly makes it the worst vote then?

Cause I'd already answered it and assumed you'd just keep reading.

you say it's the worst vote on you, so do you refute my reasoning as i just explained it? i think my vote on the wagon has the most substance to it by far, what makes it worse than a purported omgus vote, a bad meta case, and a sheep?

Worst in the sense that of the four votes, I see the most scum intention behind it, which is not much. OMGUS votes are generally NAI, I think Vizzy's blind sheeping is actually pretty towny, and I think Firebringers shitcase is actually very towny.

at first this scanned like you avoiding saying something about The Bulge specifically cuz of his more content but blep I guess I can see how The Bulge is just at the bottom cuz that's how ranking things work. Makes me wonder why you even bothered to bring it up, though.

[sheepsaysmeep]

after today im kinda busy until deadline but I dont think im gonna read enough today this is very sad

[Bingle]

at first this scanned like you avoiding saying something about The Bulge specifically cuz of his more content but blep I guess I can see how The Bulge is just at the bottom cuz that's how ranking things work. Makes me wonder why you even bothered to bring it up, though.

I brought it up because it was a thing I thought and generally it's a good policy to share the things you think that are game relevant unless there's a specific reason not to. If I bring it up, I can discuss it with people. If I don't bring it up I can do not that. One of those options has the possibility of generating readable content.