ekiM wrote:Hoopla
Why SOG over Yos D1?
Originally I thought one of Yos/Far-Cry was the godfather, had a town read on you, so technically the role I was surest of (by a psuedo-elimination process) was semioldguy being the goon. Then Yos talked me into voting semioldguy, rather than taking a shot the Godfather. Either way I feel like I was suckered into it.
ekiM wrote:Hoopla
You didn't direct a single question or to SOG after the theory discussion at the start. Why?
I think I kind of covered it in previous answer - my feelings for semioldguy were based on a process of elimination. At the time, I was more concerned about lynching the Godfather.
ekiM wrote:
At the start of D2 you said Far_Cry was towniest. Then you said He was your second lynch choice behind Yos. Then he was your first lynch choice. Can you explain the thought process here?
I think the post you're referring to is
this, which was said prior a serious reread.
Here is probably where my most cohesive thoughts for Day 2 was.
ekiM wrote:
You said you could really see Yos bussing SOG from the outset. What is that based on?
This is based on his experience. He wouldn't do it if he didn't think he could coast to the end-game - and it's these sort of posts that makes it looks like thinks he's cleared himself sufficiently;
Yosarian2 wrote:You still think I'm suspicious, Hoopla? Really?
This was straight after semi's flip and I stated he was in my top 2 for the next lynch. I think he's perfectly capable of bussing semi if he expects town credit like
that
.
While i'm at it, I want to respond to something I missed earlier;
Yosarian2 wrote:...
Damn. I was sure it had to be far cry, especally after his confession.
I've got a hard choice here. I was sure hoopla was town day 1, but I still don't know how likely it is that likely strangercoug would have gone after his scumbuddy, and the way Hoopla's been talking all game about how she's suspicious of me without ever really being able to explain it beyond "paranoia" seems bad, and convinent.
That isn't true - almost all my reads are done with a process of elimination in mind. I try and find the alignment I'm sure of and work from there. I admit paranoia is there, but not enough to skew my brain (thats what alcohol is for). My main reasoning is based on my town reads, which makes you scummy by default. Even if I have nothing on you that is empirically scummy, it doesn't cancel my town reads. In fact, it was you advocating that logic from as early as page two.
Also, I ask ekim, not to vote anyone until I'm sober please. I know I've rambled, but I have good points in there.