My guess is that at least one of the scum is considered confirmed (and the other is most likely Cesspit) and is trying to make it look like a Newb mafia in order to draw suspicion away from himself. Also, they wouldn't be able to target "confirmed" players (or players viewed as less likely to be scum) in case it gets to the endgame, and the town notices that there's just one remaining scum, and suddenly the less suspicious players have stopped being NKed.
OK, now for a tally of the lynches.
Day 1, Tidus:
tidus_of_zanarkand- 11 (
Mastermind Of Sin- 2 (Fritzler, Mr. Flay)
TheCesspit- 2 (TSAGod, Dead Rikimaru)
RandomActs- 1 (Thoth)
Fuldu- 1 (broomhead)
Not voting (3 4): JamesSparrow, Mini Neo, RandomActs, TheCesspit
Day 2, DG: Here's the full count
DrippingGoofball- 6 (LoudMouthLee, Fritzler,
LoudMouthLee- 5 (Lloyd, TSAGod, Fuldu,
PookyTheMagicalBear- 3 (Dead Rikimaru,
Fritzler- 2 (TheCesspit,
Not voting (3): broomhead, creampuffeater, JamesSparrow
Day 3, RA: again full count
RandomActs- 9 (
LoudMouthLee- 1 (Lloyd)
Twomz- 1 (
Not voting (8 ): creampuffeater, Dead Rikimaru, JamesSparrow, Mastermind of Sin, Mr. Flay, TSAGod
Day 4, NG: Full count
neongrey- 8 (Thesp, Yosarian2, creampuffeater, TheCesspit, Twomz, LoudMouthLee, Fritzler, broomhead)
Mr. Flay- 2 (
Fritzler- 2 (Mr. Flay, JamesSparrow)
TheCesspit- 2 (Dead Rikimaru, broomhead)
LoudMouthLee- 1 (Lloyd)
Not voting (1): creampuffeater
Alive
broomhead
creampuffeater
Dead Rikimaru
Fritzler
Fuldu
JamesSparrow (Replacing Hallisy)
MrBuddyLee (Replacing LoudMouthLee)
Mr. Flay
TheCesspit
Lloyd (Replacing Thoth)
Thesp (Replacing TSAGod)
Twomz
Yosarian2
Dead
Red=Mafia, Blue=Town
Conclusions: Me, LML, and Yos2 have been on all the lynch wagons. Cesspit and broomhead have been on both town lynches but niether mafia lynches.
List of people on both RA's and NG's wagon:
Me (Twomz)
Yos2
Cesspit
Fritz
LML
Broomhead
... 3 have been on all wagons, 2 have been on just town wagons, and Fritz pushed for DG's lynch. So, the 2 player's w/ the worst voting record in the game are Cesspit (The person I think is most likely to be scum) and Broomhead.