Star Wars Mafia (Game Over)

[hp [leaves]]

Vote Killa Seven

I normally don't agree with the policy lynches; but this is a special case.

[hp [leaves]]

OK guys, I think that this is pretty obvious: Wreck Star = Death Star = Empire = Scum

Unvote, Vote Wreck Star

[hp [leaves]]

Unvote, Vote Kast

For not voting.

[hp [leaves]]

@VRK- If I vote Kast, he will react. If I vote k7, he will pretty much ignore my post.

@Kast- Votes in RVS have some information in them. They can be used for scumhunting, etc. No votes mean no information.

[hp [leaves]]

Kast's posting style bothers me. It is like he wants to force us to contradict ourselves.

[hp [leaves]]

Kast's posting style bothers me. It is like he wants to force us to contradict ourselves.

You may prove me wrong, but I thought one of the best ways to find scum is to force people to slip up/contradict themselves.

Also, after putting HP in ISO, I can't say I'm very impressed with what you posted so far.

HP

Post:
1: Policy lynch on K-7.
2: Random lynch? On Wreck Star
3: Lynch on Kast for not voting
4: explanation that his vote on Kast would draw some reaction where K-7's lynch won't. Did you forget about your vote on Wreck Star or something?
5: Comment that Kast's posting style disturbs you for a crap reason.

Can you explain your vote on Wreck Star and why you keep hitting on Kast a bit more? And while you are at it, what is your opinion on Twoheadedcyclops?

Anyone will contradict himself if he is forced to answer too many questions.

Wreck Star vote was random and username related.

THC doesn't look like scum at all. He's just a townie trying to defend himself from moot cases.

http://www.philosophersnet.com/games/god.htm

OK, take the quiz above. It is filled with trick questions and will force you to contradict yourself. I get the same feeling from Kast's posts. A townie doesn't need to forcibly make people contradict themselves. Kast is scum.

[hp [leaves]]

He claimed mason. That's easily verifiable. For scum, it is not a good idea to fakeclaim mason when your partner is about to get dayvigged. One scum flip and we've found another scum.

It is a good idea to let them live.

[hp [leaves]]

You've got me wrong - An early mason claim is confirmed town until proved otherwise. The statement "THC doesn't look like scum at all." implies some amount of doubt ..

That part ignored the claim.

[hp [leaves]]

@ hp [leaves]

: How is any mason claim easily verifiable? Especially in this: a totally themed, flavored game. How do we know there aren't multiple mafia teams, multiple mason teams, etc? 2HC and Wolf could easily be a scum duo just trying to screw with our minds.

One of them dies, flips scum and the other is scum. One of them dies, flips town and the other is town. In a game this big, one of them will surely die way before lylo.

[hp [leaves]]

Oh no. Kast is going to shoot me.

Should I claim or something?

[hp [leaves]]

I'm not discouraging good scumhunting, I'm discouraging

fake

scumhunting. The kind which you do, scum. Or should I say SK with double kills? Seriously, it fits your claim so well.

I'm not claiming. Me not claiming is way better for the town.

I don't think I can convince Kast to not shooting me (obviously because he wants to shoot a townie) so expect these to be my last words. Good luck town, win this and lynch Kast the SK.

I won't be posting after this so it would make no sense to delay the daykill. Do it now.

[hp [leaves]]

Maybe HP is trying to trap someone into asking someone to claim.

Hahaha that would be so funny accusing them of rolefishing.

[hp [leaves]]

@THC-
hp is against scumhunting. That's extremely anti-town. He has no interest in cooperating with town, and simply parks himself on a crap case with no attempt or interest in developing it or discussing it with others. Post threat of day vig, he refuses to claim or share thoughts.

I am not against scum hunting. I am not against asking questions about things related to the game. I am against asking hypothetical questions.

@hp-
There are very few town roles that are beneficial to not claim.

Looks like I had one of those very few roles.

I am Bulletproof. I am not going to claim any other aspect of my role, if I have any.

I think Kast is trying to be too much of a hero, and his dayvigging skill would be better used for vigging whomever we intend to lynch as it that saves us going to night.

I agree with this. Kast fired prematurely, without waiting for a majority's approval. A town vig wouldn't act the same way. He also didn't have a strong case against me. Just some OMGUS. He also kept strawmanning that I had no interest in developing/discussing my case. In addition, I don't think a town dayvig would out himself so early. A town vig with limited kills (which I expect a dayvig would have) wouldn't shoot on day 1.

Kast is scum and needs to die.

Unvote, Vote Kast

[hp [leaves]]

You don't buy what? That I'm bulletproof?

[hp [leaves]]

Why are you guys voting me anyway?

[hp [leaves]]

I think he is scum, or more specifically SK. Or more specifically a SK with double kills and maybe NK immunity.

[hp [leaves]]

However, if you are town, you should have claimed so I don't waste a kill. If you really believed I was an SK, then obviously I would listen to a bulletproof claim and I wouldn't care about who I shot.

Soaking up a scum kill is good. I effectively saved a townie getting killed by you today.

-Bulletproof is NOT a town role that is better unclaimed. It gets revealed immediately anyway and revealing it early doesn't harm town in any way. The same is not true for scum, so perhaps you were just talking from your PoV without considering it from a town PoV.

I reply to your quote with a Tar quote:

Bulletproof Claim - Bulletproof claims always come from scum. Always, ALWAYS come from scum. Lynch such claims on sight. Yes, even if they come from a player who's been Mod-confirmed Town in the thread. It's not worth the risk.

I would lynch myself if I claimed before it was verified. Seriously.

[hp [leaves]]

I'm actually still not sure why you're still trying to lynch me.

[hp [leaves]]

Soaking up a scum kill is good. I effectively saved a townie getting killed by you today.

You effectively limited town from gaining concrete information to use in D1. You prevented town from effectively having a second lynch. Congratz, your mafia buddies must be proud of you.

-You don't like relevance do you?

Your shooting isn't effectively a second lynch. There is lot less information, no voting patterns. Actually you

could

make those happen; but you chose to ignore everyone elses ideas and OMGUSly shoot me.

[hp [leaves]]

I wouldn't claim if I believed this bandwagon wasn't pointless and mindless; but this is just... unexplainable. So here it is:

Lando Calrissian, Alliance Bulletproof One-Shot Cop. I "obtain" information like a smuggler would do.