Mini 142: Guitarists Mafia- Game Over

[Dourgrim]

Where is this whole "Dourgrim is evil" thing coming from? From IS, I'm sure it's just his twisted (and admittedly funny) method of justifying a random vote, but Assasin has me baffled...

unvote: IS

vote: Assasin

[Cubsfan4life]

Vote Count

Dourgrim- 2 (Internet Stranger, Assasin)
Mastermind of Sin- 2 (KingEnigma, tick)
Assasin- 1 (Dourgrim)
tick- 1 (Mastermind of Sin)
KingEnigma- 1 (justinl)
Talitha- 1 (Mr. Flay)
justinl- 1 (Maverick)
Mr. Flay- 1 (Talitha)

Not Voting: nonny

[Mr. Flay]

Yeah, thanks IS, that's exactly what I expected.

Talitha: Thanks, I didn't know you cared. However I'm going to follow the weirdest vote yet and

Unvote: the random Talitha, Vote: Assasin

for mindless fingering of Dourgrim. If you're always right, you might want to start explaining how...

Maverick: Why would we need to discuss potential roles unless you're searching for a claim to be able to make? Did you not turn up as a guitarist?

[Maverick]

Haha Mr. Flay.. No I definately don't need to look at potential roles to get a possible claim, if I were scum, I insure you I would know a guitarist I could make as the claim. Seeing as I'm not though, I thought we could see what the possibilities are.

I do think that was wierd, the whole assasin thing, but I'm not gonna vote for him yet. I don't want any quick bandwagons that I'm not sure about.

*I'm not sure I'll be able to post a whole lot this week, seeing I'm grounded from my computer until Friday. I will probably be able to post at school, and at friends houses though. I will attempt posting at least once per day.*

*Maverick*

[Mr. Flay]

Well, I guess I'm not sure what you meant. "Roles", as in Cop, Doc, SK, etc? Or "roles" as in Johnny Rotten, Jimi Hendrix, etc? Either way it was minor enough for me not to even FOS you... I could see some benefit to the first option, though on Day 1 we don't have a lot to go on. Probably no SK since there was only one kill last night (unless the Doc got lucky), but not a lot else to go on, unless people start mass claiming, which I don't recommend.

[Talitha]

Assassin: If you have a result or something you'd like to tell us, you might as well just say it. There's no point in dropping such obvious hints, the mafia has so much more information than the town and will spot you a mile away.

[Mastermind of Sin]

UNVOTE

now that we are getting somewhere, although still

FOS:tick

for overreacting to a random vote...

[justinl]

guys, i'd like to point out that assassin is just as new as tick (this is his first game).

[Assasin]

Justinl is correct, this is my first game, I'm still trying to get a nack for the game. Dourgrim was just my random vote and it was Mr. Flay who said

People who don't talk can't make mistakes.

not me.

[Assasin]

Sorry for the double, i hate when that happens .

[Talitha]

Mr Flay : How did you know that Assassin's vote was "mindless" and "weird"? Sounds like you know something I don't.

Sticking with my vote.

[Mastermind of Sin]

hmmm, Tally's got a point there...on the other hand, why didn't you say that in your last post, Tally? Mr. Flay has not posted since you did before, and they weren't simul-posts...

VOTE:Talitha

...I want to see where this goes...

[Talitha]

Mr Flay hadn't posted, but Assassin did, saying his vote was random.

[KingEnigma]

from the shapes of things it looks like Assasin is really only making a newbie(i really dont like that word) mistake, doesnt mean we should check him off as innocent though.

and about that vote thing at the beginning, raise your hand if you got that it was a joke.

Not so fast Mastermind of Sin and Mr Flay.

[tick]

MofS: Oh I know it was a perfectly random vote, I just like people to put more effort and make up an obvious stupid reason to justify their random vote. Much like mine was.
I really don't think I over-reacted.

although still FOS:tick for overreacting to a random vote...

hehe sounds like you are the one over-reacting to my random vote

so is dourgrim evil? I am confused about that.
IS were you just making stuff up?

[Dourgrim]

It's both a blessing and a curse: when IS is in a game, he quite often talks out his arse about a lot of things... but you can't just assume he's being full of it, because sometimes he's telling the truth (although not this time). It's a classic "boy that cried wolf" situation... the good news is, IS is so damn funny most of the time that it's hard to get mad about it.

Obviously no one is going to simply take my word for it with regards to my innocence, but it does irritate me a bit that everyone's putting so much stock into the "Dourgrim is evil" thing (especially since no Cop would ever come out on Day One... he hasn't verified his sanity yet!). And, since it seems Assasin's vote was just a weird newbie mistake (no worries, we've all made 'em!), I'm going back to my previous vote.

unvote: Assasin

vote: IS

[Dourgrim]

Bloody hell, this (triple?!) posting problem is getting bad.

MOD: mind deleting two of those for me?

[Cubsfan4life]

All "extra" posts have been deleted.

[Internet Stranger]

I didnt realize that this was supposed tp be a newbie game. Do I need to put disclaimers with every post?

Dourgrim being evil is the same was saying its a random vote. Why would I vote someone if I dont think they were evil scum? The fact is that NONE of you know ANYTHING. Not yet at least.

So you pick someone at random, lynch them, and hope for the best. This time around, Dourgrim is the one I picked and hence, the winner of the Day 1 bandwagon. So lets hop to it, pile on the votes and show him how popular he really is.

[Mastermind of Sin]

MofS: Oh I know it was a perfectly random vote, I just like people to put more effort and make up an obvious stupid reason to justify their random vote. Much like mine was.
I really don't think I over-reacted.

although still FOS:tick for overreacting to a random vote...

hehe sounds like you are the one over-reacting to my random vote

so is dourgrim evil? I am confused about that.
IS were you just making stuff up?

meh, whatever...works for me...

UNFOS:tick

for now...

[Mastermind of Sin]

Mr Flay hadn't posted, but Assassin did, saying his vote was random.

wrong. Mr. Flay posted in post 27 AND post 29, and you posted right after him in post 31, over two hours later, but didn't post your suspicion about Mr. Flay until post 35, and Mr. Flay had not posted anything since your last post to make you more suspicious of him...

[Mr. Flay]

Okay, in reverse order:

IS: I'm sure it goes without saying, but I *hate* your playing style. You post in such choppy, disjointed, unexplained bursts that I usually can't get a good read on you. However this:

The fact is that NONE of you know ANYTHING. Not yet at least.

...makes me at least a little suspicious, because surely investigative roles would have something to go on by now?!? Sanity can be questioned, sure, but it's not like this was a newbie game with no Night One... I'd vote you if I thought it would do any good.

Dourgrim: I don't think that "everyone" is taking IS's "Dourgrim is evil" thing so seriously...by my count, only two people have voted you yet, out of 12. I'm certainly not convinced by his arguments (or lack thereof).

Talitha:

How did you know that Assassin's vote was "mindless" and "weird"? Sounds like you know something I don't.

Actually, at that point you knew more than I did, since Assasin had finally explained that his initial vote on Dourgrim was random (can you honestly read back on post 19 and tell me that didn't look weird?). If he was trying to play like IS, it failed in my opinion...nobody can play like IS except IS (see above), and even that doesn't mean I'm going to give him a free pass. That being said,

Unvote: Assasin

for now... newbie mistakes happen, though I'm not 100% convinced.

Finally, KingEnigma, what are you going on about?

Not so fast Mastermind of Sin and Mr Flay.

Your first post of the day was to vote for MoS for a *stated random* vote, and claim that proves he's scum. Why? Because he was the first one to vote? Because you couldn't post until 3 whole minutes later? I FOS'ed you because it seemed like

crap logic

... I know you won't agree with me, but I wasn't interested in your opinion at that moment. You'd already made it abundantly clear... I wanted to see what other people thought of you.

With all of that said, my review of the thread right now boils down to IS or Maverick. Maverick has posted all of twice, and the thing about asking for roles in his first post still makes my hackles rise. Also, for only posting twice and apparently having limited access, he sure responded quickly to me in 10 minutes, when questioned... sounds like a perfect recipe for lurkerdom in my book.

So

Vote: Maverick

to see if he shows up, while keeping a

FOS on InternetStranger

.

[nonny]

We can talk on Day 2. Day 1 is for following IS mindlessly.

How many times have you been right? does seem like it's all the often

No vote now.

[Talitha]

Mr Flay hadn't posted, but Assassin did, saying his vote was random.

wrong. Mr. Flay posted in post 27 AND post 29, and you posted right after him in post 31, over two hours later, but didn't post your suspicion about Mr. Flay until post 35, and Mr. Flay had not posted anything since your last post to make you more suspicious of him...

After Assassin clarified that his vote was

random, it made me suspicious of Mr Flay. Because

my

first impression of Assassin's vote was that he had some information. Mr Flay seemed to

know without being told

that there was no information behind Assassin's vote.

Actually, at that point you knew more than I did, since Assasin had finally explained that his initial vote on Dourgrim was random (can you honestly read back on post 19 and tell me that didn't look weird?).

It looked like a vote from someone who knew something to me. I didn't jump to the conclusion that it was a mindless vote. The fact that you did jump to that conclusion (and were right!), is why I am voting for you. If you know that Dour is innocent because you're scum, you'd know that Assassin's vote was weird and mindless.

[Internet Stranger]

Great this means we can sort a bunch of things out when we lynch Dourgrim. So lets do it.