Nanosauromo wrote:
CKD wrote:so if Battlemage is the Miller, then what armix?
If BM does turn up dead and he was indeed the Miller, then I think we should go after Armix.
well, that means that the lyncher wins right? We get second like in the case of the jester, right?
Antithesis wrote:
The Battlemage thing... a question for the veterans here. Is BM considered a strong townie player? By this I mean, does he have a rep as a strong scum hunter? If so, I do wonder why he wasn't targeted night one then.
In my dealings with BM, I find he tends to be a poor scum hunter. He tends to tunnel vision (I would be a hypocrite if I didnt admit to doing this too). But that is just in the games I am in with him, we tend to bump heads a lot. However, BM does have a ton of experience, so who knows. I believe the Miller claim, I would rather leave the testing of him being scum to the vig, if he deems BM scummy...I am not directing the vig, but I think it would be safer for the town (if I am understand the Miller/lyncher relationship with the town correctly)
Ok I just went to reread the Miller role...in both games I have played with a miller, there was a lyncher (I think)...can you have a miller without a lyncher, then? Has anyone ever played in a game where the Miller knew he was a Miller? I assume they are out there or BM and ST would not have had the discussion....